- Mamdani calls the business chatbot “functionally unusable” and orders it removed
- The chatbot repeatedly gave incorrect or illegal advice to city business owners
- Ex-mayor Adams defended the system, claiming improvements would make it the best chatbot
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has announced plans to shutter a business chatbot launched under Mayor Eric Adams’s administration, calling it “functionally unusable.”
At a recent press conference addressing the city’s $12 billion budget gap, Mamdani said the chatbot was costing the city around half a million dollars while giving unreliable guidance to business owners.
The bot, called MyCity Chatbot, was originally designed to serve as a productivity tool for business owners, helping them navigate city rules and regulations.
Chatbot gave false and illegal responses
Testing by The Markup and The City in 2024 found it regularly gave inaccurate or potentially illegal advice.
For example, it suggested landlords could discriminate against Section 8 tenants and incorrectly advised businesses that refusing cash payments was acceptable, despite city law.
The tool also misrepresented labor rules, such as minimum wage, and recommended actions that could expose business owners to legal risk.
Mamdani cited these repeated failures as the main justification for his decision to terminate the service.
After initial reports, the Adams administration defended the chatbot and promised future improvements.
“We’re identifying what the problems are, we’re gonna fix them, and we’re going to have the best chatbot system on the globe,” Adams said.
However, the city later added disclaimers warning users not to rely on the bot for legal or professional advice.
The chatbot also restricted the types of questions it would answer, which reduced its usefulness as a collaboration tool for businesses.
Built using Microsoft’s cloud hosting platform, the bot was part of the MyCity digital overhaul intended to streamline access to city services.
The foundation reportedly cost nearly $600,000, and ongoing maintenance added further expense, although exact figures remain unclear.
Beyond financial concerns, the system relied heavily on outside contractors and complex office software, which contributed to inefficiencies and limited usability.
Despite several restrictions and updates, the tool reportedly continued to produce harmful or incorrect guidance.
Mamdani’s decision highlights the risks of deploying automated systems as public-facing tools without adequate oversight.
Via The City
Follow TechRadar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!
And of course you can also follow TechRadar on TikTok for news, reviews, unboxings in video form, and get regular updates from us on WhatsApp too.
https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/4Wmp6ZgmisSiVzrcwvGwND-1920-80.jpg
Source link
