56 Years Ago, Paul McCartney Did What No One Else Would and Ended The Beatles for Good

Since the news of The Beatles’ break-up first officially broke in 1970, it has been framed as a definitive decision by Paul McCartney. While, yes, this is technically true, the reality was far less sudden, shaped instead by a series of cracks forming away from the spotlight. Before the public had the chance to catch on, each band member had already begun questioning their place within The Beatles.

Creative tension and the ludicrous pressures of fame pushed John Lennon, George Harrison, and Ringo Starr to briefly walk away and even threaten to leave at various stages of the late 1960s. These uncomfortable moments were, unfortunately, not just heated arguments but signals of increasingly unbearable tension. So, when McCartney made it official, the idea of The Beatles breaking up was no longer unthinkable but, perhaps, inevitable.

Paul McCartney Wasn’t The Only Beatles Member Who Wanted Out

Before any official break-up announcements were ever made, each of the Beatles’ members had actually walked away from the group at one stage, but always returned following their respective spats. Ringo Starr left for two weeks in the summer of 1968, but returned from his vacation with flowers on his drum kit as a peace offering that convinced him to stay. Like Ringo, George Harrison walked away from The Beatles for five days during the Get Back sessions in January 1969, when tensions were growing, and the group was being filmed for the Peter Jackson documentary. Harrison looked back at the difficulties, asking, “What’s the point of this? […] Everybody had gone through that. Ringo had left at one point. I know John wanted out. It was a very, very difficult, stressful time, and being filmed having a row as well was terrible. I got up, and I thought, ‘I’m not doing this anymore. I’m out of here.’” Harrison returned on the condition that The Beatles stop plans for live performance and that they move the recording to their new Apple basement studio.

Related

The Beatles Said No to This George Harrison Song — Then It Became a Classic Hit

George Harrison brought this iconic song to a Beatles rehearsal and it was rejected.

Months later, in September 1969, John Lennon privately shared that he wanted to quit by saying he wanted to “divorce” The Beatles. This comment felt particularly weighty, as The Beatles’ output was, arguably unfairly, dependent on the writing partnership of Lennon and McCartney. So, the breakdown of such a creatively powerful duo looked like the beginning of the end. Lennon’s strained decision also aligned with the emergence of The Plastic Ono Band, which perhaps gave Lennon a sense of creative freedom he felt The Beatles no longer provided.

Paul McCartney Finally Decided To Let The Beatles Be

Shortly after Lennon’s desire for separation, McCartney echoed the sentiment in Life Magazine. He expressed a simultaneous nostalgic longing for the old days and a need to move forward: “I would rather do what I began by doing, which is making music. We make good music and we want to go on making good music. But the Beatle thing is over. It has been exploded, partly by what we have done, and partly by other people. We are individuals—all different.” McCartney acknowledged the immense tension between a group of such musically strong individuals and hinted at a struggle between egos as well. It’s also a touch of class and reassuring self-awareness that McCartney identified the enormous pressure caused by the interference of fame and how that could affect the well-being of young men.

What seemed to be the ultimate catalyst for the break-up of The Beatles was the final few months of grappling with Apple Records, the record label founded by the band in 1968. The appointment of business manager Allen Klein was strongly resisted by McCartney, who instead favored his own father-in-law for the position. After that, McCartney refused to attend meetings, clarifying that the feeling of friendship had dwindled along with business camaraderie. By then, one could imagine it would seem like a stretch to find creative catharsis when even mundane business matters felt tedious.

Related

After Their Heartbreaking Split, Ringo Starr Managed to Reunite All Four Beatles on This Album

A surprising collaboration that sparked hope of a reunion.

McCartney’s official departure was covered in the Daily Mirror newspaper on April 10, 1970, as part of a self-interview. The breaking story was confirmed with McCartney’s exit statement: “I have no future plans to record or appear with the Beatles again or to write any more music with John.” In retrospect, it feels a little odd to know there was a definitive day on which the news was announced, quite a while after it had been bubbling for so long. However, it also makes total sense that McCartney was the one to do it. The other band members had already established solo projects throughout their Beatles careers (Lennon with the Plastic Ono Band, Ringo with films, and Harrison with production and solo material), so it was up to McCartney to officially close a door that was already shut. His announcement then marked the inevitability of his own eventual solo album, McCartney, the final mark of The Beatles’ dissolution.

In 1970, after the split, McCartney revealed that “Leaving the Beatles, or having the Beatles leave me, whichever way you look at it, was very difficult because that was my life’s job.” But there was no need for him to worry. Paul McCartney has gained 83 Grammy nominations and 19 wins, including nine with The Beatles, two with Wings, a collaboration with Nirvana, and two lifetime achievement awards. He also holds the Guinness World Record for the most No. 1 hits as a songwriter. The Beatles didn’t fall apart overnight after McCartney’s announcement, but it relieved some of the mounting pressure. By the time it was official, The Beatles had formed their own legacies, shaped their own identities, and continued to define music history in their unique ways.