Why The Odyssey’s Rotten Tomatoes Score Is So Close To Perfect

Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey has already received a Rotten Tomatoes score just shy of perfect. Christopher Nolan has spent the better part of two decades turning original blockbusters and ambitious adaptations into must-see theatrical events. His dynamic narrative structures and epic sensibilities tend to generate enormous expectations. With The Odyssey, those expectations may have been higher than ever.

Adapting one of the oldest and most influential stories ever written is a challenge that would intimidate most filmmakers. Homer’s epic poem The Odyssey has inspired countless adaptations over the centuries, but translating its monsters, gods, battles, and emotional themes into a modern blockbuster is another matter entirely. The project was also accompanied by a reported $250 million budget, an all-star ensemble cast, and the distinction of being the first narrative feature shot entirely using 70mm IMAX cameras. Critics were always going to examine every frame under a microscope.

Instead of collapsing under that pressure, The Odyssey has emerged as one of the most acclaimed films of Nolan’s career. The movie currently sits at 96% on Rotten Tomatoes and has been described by numerous reviewers as one of the year’s best films, with some even calling it Nolan’s crowning achievement.

Critics have singled out everything from its massive scale and practical effects to its performances and emotional depth. While The Odyssey isn’t completely free of criticism, the reasons behind its near-perfect score are remarkably consistent across reviews.

The Odyssey Reviews Praise The Scope, Thematic Depth, And Cast

The most common theme among reviews is that The Odyssey successfully balances gigantic spectacle with surprisingly intimate character work. Critics have repeatedly highlighted the immense scale, with several reviewers arguing that Nolan has delivered one of the most ambitious fantasy epics ever put on screen. Publications including The Telegraph, The Guardian, Empire, and TheWrap praised the combination of large-scale action, practical filmmaking, and emotional storytelling.

Many reviews have also focused on The Odyssey’s exploration of trauma and survival. Rather than simply presenting Odysseus’ journey as a string of monster encounters and adventures, critics noted that Nolan reframes the story as an examination of a soldier struggling with PTSD after war. This psychological angle appears to have resonated strongly with reviewers.

The cast has received similarly enthusiastic praise. Matt Damon has been singled out by multiple critics for delivering one of the strongest performances of his career, portraying Odysseus as a heroic figure whose determination is matched by exhaustion, regret, and stubbornness. Anne Hathaway’s Penelope has also earned praise for bringing strength and vulnerability to a role that could easily have become passive.

Tom Holland’s mature performance as Telemachus has impressed reviewers, while Robert Pattinson’s Antinous and Samantha Morton’s Circe are frequently mentioned as scene-stealers. The fact that so many members of the enormous ensemble have received individual praise goes a long way toward explaining why critics have responded so enthusiastically.

Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey Received Criticism For Editing And Sound

Finding negative reviews of The Odyssey requires considerably more searching than finding positive ones, but a handful of critics have highlighted recurring issues. One complaint involves the film’s pacing. While many reviewers praised The Odyssey’s momentum, some critics argued that Nolan moves through Homer’s episodic story too quickly.

Certain sequences reportedly feel more like highlights than fully developed chapters, with little downtime between major events. A few reviewers felt it rarely pauses long enough for audiences to absorb what’s happening before moving on to the next spectacle. Others suggested that quieter character moments may have been trimmed in favor of maintaining momentum.

Because Homer’s story naturally consists of a series of adventures, some detractors felt the movie occasionally sacrifices emotional clarity for scale and pace. Sound mixing, a criticism that has followed Nolan throughout much of his career, also appears in some of the less favorable reviews. Certain critics argued that dialogue can become difficult to understand during key scenes, making an already dense story harder to follow.

Combined with darker lighting in some sequences, this reportedly created confusion for viewers unfamiliar with the source material. Even many positive reviews acknowledge minor pacing issues. However, the consensus appears to be that these flaws are relatively small when compared to the film’s achievements.

Is The Odyssey Worth Seeing In Theaters?

Even critics who had reservations about the story generally agreed on one thing: The Odyssey was designed for the biggest screen possible. Nolan has spent years championing theatrical exhibition, and this project may be his strongest argument yet for seeing movies in cinemas rather than waiting for streaming.

The groundbreaking production format is a major part of that recommendation. As the first narrative feature shot entirely on 70mm IMAX cameras, The Odyssey was specifically engineered to take advantage of giant screens and premium presentation formats. Reviewers have repeatedly described Hoyte van Hoytema’s cinematography as breathtaking, with enormous landscapes, practical effects, and large-scale action sequences that benefit tremendously from theatrical exhibition.

The nearly three-hour runtime may be intimidating for some viewers. At 172 minutes, it’s a substantial commitment, particularly given the dense mythology and complex themes. Those unfamiliar with Homer’s story may occasionally find themselves working to keep up.

Still, for Nolan fanatics, epic fantasy enthusiasts, and anyone interested in seeing cutting-edge filmmaking technology pushed to its limits, the theatrical experience appears to be the whole point. The reviews suggest that even when The Odyssey stumbles, it does so while attempting something genuinely enormous. And judging by that 96% Rotten Tomatoes score, most critics believe Nolan succeeded spectacularly.

Release Date

July 17, 2026

Runtime

172 Minutes