[
With their combination of astonishing visual wonder, immaculate narrative precision, and ability to conjure escapist awe while still finding depth and nuance, the greatest fantasy movies stand as universally adored triumphs of cinema. From Hollywood epics like The Lord of the Rings to international animations like Spirited Away, the genre is full of iconic masterpieces that epitomize filmmaking perfection. But what of the many fantasy movies that aren’t quite as good?
This isn’t to say these movies are flawed or faulted, only that, for whatever reason, film culture doesn’t view them with the same reverence and absolute adoration as it does the genre’s most esteemed triumphs (a long, long list including everything from The Seventh Seal to Shrek). Ranging from underrated cult classics to overlooked Hollywood hits, from rollicking action-adventures to animated gems, these fantasy treats are about as close to cinematic perfection as is possible without attaining it.
‘Dungeons and Dragons: Honor Among Thieves’ (2023)
Those who are old enough would fondly look back 20 years to an era that was dominated by Harry Potter, The Lord of the Rings, and Pirates of the Caribbean and wonder what happened to the genre’s prominence. While superhero movies and blockbuster sci-fi dominate today’s market, the pure escapist glee of fantasy seems scarce, a shame that Dungeons and Dragons: Honor Among Thieves sought to remedy upon release in 2023, only to face financial hardship upon release, despite earning critical acclaim.
Spirited and sprightly, it follows a charming thief and his ragtag band of adventurers as their efforts to steal a long-lost relic from a wealthy lord lead to them being the last hope to stand against an evil magic that will descend upon the realm. The heroes are a joy to cheer for, the action is frequent, fun, and breezy, and the playfulness of the storytelling holds an unabashed charm that feels refreshing in modern blockbuster cinema. While there is a whiff of MCU-style quippiness on display, it is mostly controlled, making for an entertaining fantasy adventure.
‘The Bishop’s Wife’ (1947)
Old Hollywood fantasy faced obvious limitations with regard to practical possibilities, but whatever it may have lacked in filmmaking craft, it aspired to make up for with storytelling prowess. A quaint Christmas classic, The Bishop’s Wife occupies an air of warmth and wonder as it follows Dudley (Cary Grant), an angel sent down from heaven to help the misguided Bishop Henry Brougham (David Niven). However, when Dudley falls in love with Mrs. Brougham (Loretta Young), the godsend begins to grow conflicted about his duty.
The film blends suave wit, gentle-handed theology, and grounded emotional stakes superbly, using the romantic angst to answer Brougham’s prayer for guidance. Even featuring a couple of very early and adorable special effects shots, The Bishop’s Wife hits at the heart of grounded fantasy, delivering a Christmas classic that deserves far more celebration than it receives. Indeed, it lives in the shadow of other Old Hollywood masterpieces like It’s a Wonderful Life and Miracle on 34th Street when the festive season comes around.
‘The Fall’ (2006)
Directed by Tarsem Singh, The Fall marks one of the most astonishing production feats in the history of fantasy cinema. Filmed over four years, using locations in 24 different countries, it creates a spellbinding viewing experience without ever resorting to CGI. Every surreal palace, picturesque desert, and mesmerizing landscape is a real-world location, and that palpable visual majesty has a tremendous impact on the audience, especially with the stunning costumes having their time to shine as well
However, The Fall isn’t simply a procession of beautiful shots. It delivers a touching tale about the impact of storytelling, with a paralyzed silent-era movie stuntman relaying an epic fairytale of heroism and honor to a young girl with a broken arm in a 1920s hospital. Anchored by the touching dynamic between the stuntman and the little girl, it marks a sublime achievement in fantasy filmmaking, and it is a shame more people haven’t seen it.
‘Barbie’ (2023)
Barbie generated an immediate reaction from viewers with its striking combination of commanding allegorical storytelling and candy-colored fantasy worldbuilding. While Barbie (Margot Robbie) lives in the plastic paradise of Barbie Land, her world is shattered when she is forced to venture into the real world to save herself from “real” thoughts of death and cellulite. Her journey exposes Ken (Ryan Gosling) to the patriarchy and inspires him to instill a similar social structure in Barbie Land.
Greta Gerwig finds a wonderful balance between playful absurdity and piercing thematic depth. Just because the social satire comes in pretty pink and cowboy outfits doesn’t make it any less precise or pressing. From a pure fantasy perspective, Barbie delivers great worldbuilding from the outset, grounds viewers in the rules and regime of Barbie Land, and blends the Mattel realm with a real-world setting to perfection. Even Barbie’s “Chosen One” character journey captures the essence of fantasy storytelling. The result is a mighty and memorable fantasy-comedy that juggles bold ideas and comedic chaos with aplomb.
‘Time Bandits’ (1981)
Terry Gilliam’s eclectic career has come to be defined by its boldness and conviction, qualities that have lent themselves to plenty of cult genre gems over the years. One of the best and most adored is 1981’s fantasy adventure Time Bandits, which follows an 11-year-old boy who is whisked away on a bizarre adventure. Six time-traveling dwarves appear in his bedroom, jumping from era to era in search of hidden treasure while meeting such historical figures as Napoleon Bonaparte (Ian Holm), Robin Hood (John Cleese), and King Agamemnon (Sean Connery).
In addition to flaunting an invigorating story of historical adventure, Time Bandits also soars off the back of its exuberant set design and quirky special effects, both of which create a distinct and vivid viewing experience. While it was a box office success upon release, Time Bandits has sadly faded from memory, and some of its eccentricities do age it somewhat, but it remains an easily admired gem of fantasy whimsy.
‘Ponyo’ (2008)
It’s tough to find any Hayao Miyazaki movie that isn’t an outright masterpiece. His fantasy filmography alone is defined by such iconic titles as Spirited Away, My Neighbor Totoro, and Princess Mononoke (among many others). Ponyo is truly exceptional in its own right, but it struggles to rise to the same awe-inspiring level as Miyazaki’s other movies. It follows the friendship that blooms between a young boy and the goldfish princess he saves, who uses her father’s magic to transform into a young girl as she starts to fall in love.
Enriched by the beauty of the hand-drawn animation, Ponyo is a wondrous illustration of magic from the perspective of a child. However, it never lessens its thematic impact. The story explores the delicate balance between humanity and nature with compelling depth, with the antagonistic presence of Ponyo’s (Yuuri Nara/Noah Cyrus) overprotective father grounded in his dismay at how humanity treats the ocean rather than any sense of evil or ambition. Exceptional storytelling, visuals, and even a sneakily outstanding ensemble cast make Ponyo a quintessential Studio Ghibli hit even if it isn’t the defining masterpiece of Japanese animation.
‘Return to Oz’ (1985)
The 1980s are a goldmine of cult fantasy cinema, producing such beloved masterworks as The Princess Bride and Excalibur. Beneath those iconic titles is a litany of underrated gems, with 1985’s The Wizard of Oz sequel chief among them. It marks one of the most auspicious releases in Hollywood history, an unflinching return to the beloved fantasy realm that exists more as a nightmarish children’s horror movie rather than a rekindling of the musical adventure of the first film.
Following Dorothy (Fairuza Balk) as she escapes from a psychiatric facility and ventures back to Oz only to find it as a diminished, ruined kingdom under the control of an evil empire, Return to Oz aspires to be much more aligned with L. Frank Baum’s eerie source material. The approach certainly made an impact on contemporary audiences who were expecting something more like The Wizard of Oz, but it was soon forgotten by critics and audiences alike soon after. The shame is that Return to Oz finds an invigorating, evocative balance between adventure and horror that encapsulates dark fantasy wonder at its most alluring.
‘Stardust’ (2007)
A criminally underrated gem of 21st-century cinema, Stardust is an engrossing, feel-good treat of fantasy excess that combines the fairy tale allure of the genre with wry humor, high stakes, and a stunning ensemble cast. Charlie Cox stars as Tristan, a young man from an English village who vows to retrieve a fallen star from the magical realm of Stormhold to win over his love. However, the star is a young woman, Yvaine (Claire Danes), being hunted for her powers by evil witches and murderous princes.
Between the romantic core of Tristan and Yvaine’s complex yet beautifully evolving dynamic, Michelle Pfiefer’s delightfully wicked performance, Robert De Niro’s unforgettable turn as a flamboyant sky pirate, and a litany of adventurous and daring fight sequences, Stardust epitomizes fantasy fun at its most absorbing. Its at-times sporadic tonal shifts and some minor uses of CGI that haven’t aged gracefully are all that prevent it from being a perfect masterpiece of the genre, and even then it is incredibly close.
‘Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest’ (2006)
It is quite bizarre to think that Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest holds a meager 53% on Rotten Tomatoes and was dismissed by many critics as a lazy cash grab. While this didn’t hurt its box office performance—it grossed over $1 billion—it has made for an interesting case of audience approval clashing with critical consensus. Over time, the average moviegoer has been proven right, with Dead Man’s Chest shining even 20 years later as a rollicking fantasy adventure.
Its story alone is expertly handled, a lively and unrelenting dose of character-driven fun that sees Captain Jack Sparrow (Johnny Depp), William Turner (Orlando Bloom), and Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightley) all hunt for the heart of Davy Jones (Bill Nighy) to further their agendas. Complimented by its peerless, ageless visual effects and gorgeous cinematography, Hans Zimmer’s divine score, a litany of iconic performances, and engrossing, seafaring adventure, Dead Man’s Chest is a worthy successor to Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl. It stands strong as a near-perfect fantasy blockbuster that has only gotten better as the years have gone on.
‘Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban’ (2004)
If anyone were to suggest that Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban does stand as a genuine feat of fantasy perfection, it would be difficult to argue. The third film in the Harry Potter franchise, it soars off the back of Alfonso Cuarón’s direction, straying a little deeper into the looming darkness of the fantasy world without completely abandoning the childlike fun that defines the adventurous spirit of its two predecessors. This tonal balance makes it a popular fan favorite within the series, an endlessly rewatchable gem of fantasy cinema.
The story sees Harry Potter (Daniel Radcliffe) navigate a tumultuous year at Hogwarts with convict Sirius Black (Gary Oldman) escaping from Azkaban, supposedly with the intention of killing Potter. Cuarón builds the wonder and suspense magnificently, accruing a sense of narrative momentum that reaches its infectious peak when Harry and Hermione (Emma Watson) use a time-turner to alter the events of a grim and fateful evening. The kinetic, ever-evolving story works beautifully in tandem with the dreary, almost-Gothic visual style and a litany of excellent performances from established characters and new introductions alike.
https://static0.colliderimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/margot-robbie_barbie-2023.jpg?w=1600&h=900&fit=crop
https://collider.com/best-fantasy-movies-close-to-perfect/
Ryan Heffernan
Almontather Rassoul




