Embark Studios Responds to Backlash After Replacing Casters for The Finals’ Grand Major Qualifier Highlights With Game’s AI Commentators



[

The Grand Major, an official tournament for Embark Studios’ first-person shooter The Finals, is at the center of a heated debate after the developer replaced its real-life esports casters with AI commentators in a now-deleted highlight reel.

Embark Studios is facing backlash after a now-deleted video was uploaded to The Finals’ official social media accounts recapping highlights from The Grand Major’s APAC Closed Qualifiers. The audio commentary that played over the video is at the center of this blowback, as the casters who originally commentated these matches were replaced by the game’s fictional AI commentators, Scotty and June. While this video has since been removed from public viewing, remarks from casters in the community paint a grim picture of what they saw.

“After four cycles, open/closed [qualifiers], the time, effort, passion, and emotion myself, @TheeHyperactive, and @bluepanda_casts put in, we get replaced by two AI casters who even quote us. I get they are a part of the game, but yikes. Thanks @reachthefinals,” commentator Proto / Kai wrote in a viral post on Twitter/X.

Caster Bluepanda also spoke out on the situation, writing, “For nearly seven years I’ve been repeatedly told that my work is valued and appreciated, only to then have the same people saying those things turn around and either completely ghost me or tell me they’re going in a different direction with talent and that my services aren’t needed. GG.”

The ordeal soon caught fire within the general esports scene, with casters from various competitive gaming communities speaking out against Embark’s decision to use AI as a replacement for the actual casters whose knowledge, charisma, and talent are being trained on without their knowledge or consent.

“Oh! Esports has AI casters now! Haha! I am appalled. These REAL casters deserve better, and stealing their quotes is disgusting. Y’know what’s worse? THE CASTING IS TERRIBLE. Everyone involved in making this should be embarrassed,” Marvel Rivals caster LemonKiwi wrote.

The Finals Gameplay Screenshots

“AI casters trained on the actual casters is devious, damn,” fighting game commentator Damascus tweeted. “Every day we keep moving towards the absolute slop era.”

Some players are pointing to a new feature for The Finals that was announced back in October called Dynamic Commentary. It uses the game’s pre-existing, fictional commentators Scotty and June, who are now able to refer to players by their screen names and even call out specific moments in individual matches based on the context of what’s happening in the game.

It’s worth noting that the voices of Scotty and June were provided by human voice actors who were paid by Embark for their work. However, their lines are driven by a text-to-speech program and an artificial intelligence model that was trained on their voices, leading some players to argue that the writing for this AI esports commentary debacle has been on the wall for some time now.

I reached out to Embark Studios for comment on the situation. In its response, the company explained that it had chosen to use Scotty and June to introduce The Grand Major due to players’ familiarity with the characters, but ultimately decided that this wasn’t the right direction to take, given the hard work provided by the matches’ original commentators and talent. The full statement can be read below:

“Yesterday, we released a recap video of THE FINALS APAC Closed Qualifier, narrated by Scotty and June, using familiar characters to introduce more players to THE FINALS esports ahead of The Grand Major. The video was a highlight recap, and our team selected clips from the broadcast, wrote an original script and produced new commentary for Scotty and June. However, leaving out the casters and talent who made that broadcast wasn’t the right call. We’ve taken the video down, and the AMER and EMEA recaps in the same format will no longer be released. We’re grateful to our talent for their candid feedback.”

Oscar Lundberg, Competitive Experience and Community at Embark Studios and The Finals, published a statement on his personal Twitter/X account responding to the blowback, as well.

“Yesterday we released a recap of the APAC Closed Qualifier that left out the casters and talent who made that event. That was a mistake, and I’m sorry,” he wrote. “We intended for Scotty and June to help bring more casual interest into THE FINALS esports ahead of TGM. That was the goal, but the work of our talent deserved to be included and highlighted, and it wasn’t. The video is down and won’t return in this form. The AMER and EMEA recaps planned in the same format won’t go out as planned either, and we’re rethinking all three.”

I also spoke with two of the commentators who worked on The Finals’ competitive circuit, both of whom were not chosen to commentate The Grand Major despite providing their talents for multiple tournaments leading up to the event. As Lundberg mentioned, this was just one of three highlight videos planned for each competing region using this type of AI audio commentary in place of the actual casters.

“Embark saw no issue with this until they received overwhelming global backlash and even then their response was essentially, ‘Whoopsie, we didn’t think people would mind,'” Bluepanda told me. “It says to me that they’re not really sorry at all. I’m done with the game and esports as a whole at this stage, the effort we put in and the amount of bulls**t we have to deal with, especially in OCE, just isn’t worth it anymore.”

Proto, who commented all four cycles throughout the year, on top of working the open and closed qualifiers, echoed this sentiment and relayed how the situation was explained to him by Embark’s organizers.

“It’s definitely pretty tragic that they assumed that would be the right step forward,” he said. “…They had an idea of the story that they wanted to tell for the teams and the qualifier. They looked through the VOD, found clips and moments that told that story, then wrote a script of what they roughly wanted Scotty and June to say. The script was handed off to an individual who writes the script, and then the line creation was done, and they didn’t feed the VOD itself into the AI, but essentially they still ripped parts of the VOD of things that we said, which is why they copy things we said.”

Proto went on to warn others in the industry that this debacle could be the proverbial canary in the coal mine for esports talent; much like the AI-generated menus we now see plastered on the exterior every restaurant, it’s possible that one day, esports circuits no longer see the point in paying for flesh and blood talent when an AI is far cheaper.

“Opening that door is almost like Pandora’s Box,” Proto said. “As soon as it opens and people think that this is something that can be done, it creates problems for the talent who are pouring their heart and soul into these broadcasts. It just essentially takes away any kind of relevance from us in terms of, ‘Why did we even bother?’ I mean, they paid us to do this show. …It was decent money. Why would you throw that away to dub us over with AI? It just didn’t make any sense. And in terms of the longevity of the scene, I think this definitel opens up the ability for people now to experiment with [AI], if that’s what they want to do, they can get rid of their talents.”

As far as next steps are concerned, Proto says that all esports talent — be that casters, producers, broadcasters, camera operators, or even PAs — need to create a union to protect themselves from this exact type of mishap.

“I think industry wide, we definitely need to implement some kind of protection for commentary teams as well as production teams,” he said. “There has to be some kind of something set up, whether it’s a union, whether it’s a global talent hiatus. We’ll turn around and say, ‘We’re not doing this until people send us contracts that essentially ban the use of our voices in generative AI.’ But this is why I include production, as well. If we’ve got people making streaming broadcasting packages or people running production on the back end of things, switching all the cameras, doing the observing, there are features that have auto-AI observe like in Counter-Strike, you can follow people from that third person perspective or even in the finals when people die, the camera will sort of just start flicking between people automatically. You got to protect those people’s jobs.”

But where Embark is concerned, Proto is calling for immediate and sweeping change. This includes widening the talent pool for major tournaments, providing a “more streamlined” version of next year’s competitive events, and supporting local communities to keep the game’s competitive scene alive.

“Everything has just been handled so poorly consistently to the point where even the talent announcement for the major, everybody wasn’t happy. It’s just been, and I say this brazenly, it’s been a sh*t show. It’s been a sh*t show,” he said.

The Finals isn’t the only game from Embark that uses AI; Arc Raiders also utilizes artificial intelligence for voice lines that, similar to The Finals’ Dynamic Commentary, are able to call out specific items and locations.

In a November 2025 interview with PCGamesN, design director Virgil Watkins explained that Embark had “hire[d] and contract[ed] voice actors for it,” saying it was “part of their contract that we use [AI] for this purpose, and that allows us to do things like our ping system, where it’s capable of saying every single item name, every single location name, and compass directions. That’s how we can get that without needing to have someone come in every time we create a new item for the game.”

Overall, it seems that most fans are in agreement that using AI for NPCs and player character dialogue is one thing, but replacing real-life commentators who poured hours into analysis with AI is another ball of wax, entirely.

Virginia Glaze Avatar

Virginia (she/her) is IGN’s News Editor. With ten years of experience reporting on games and entertainment, she’s got a storied background in the fighting game community, influencer news, and viral online trends. Find her on Twitter at @TheeMissGlaze. 

https://assets-prd.ignimgs.com/2026/11/17/the-finals-casters-speak-out-1794959859365.jpg?width=1280&format=jpg&auto=webp&quality=80
https://www.ign.com/articles/its-been-a-shtshow-esports-casters-call-for-change-after-embark-studios-replaces-talent-for-the-finals-grand-major-qualifier-highlight-reel-with-games-ai-commentators


Virginia Glaze
Almontather Rassoul

Latest articles

spot_imgspot_img

Related articles

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

spot_imgspot_img