[
The great Eagles debate has been around for decades, but the Lord of the Rings franchise adds another great argument to the discussion. While Prime Video’s The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power is full of creative liberties, most of which stem from the source material’s lack of a traditional narrative, it can still contribute to canon in a variety of ways. Season 3 provides an example of this, as the Eagles that lent Gandalf so much help in the central trilogy allowed Galadriel to escape the Dark Lord at Mount Gundabad.
Before we dive into what this moment says about The Lord of the Rings, let’s take a look at the debate over the Eagles. Near the end of The Return of the King, when Frodo and Sam destroyed the One Ring, Gandalf appeared on the backs of the ethereal, godlike Eagles and flew the two hobbits to safety. This easy travel solution brought up what many considered a plot hole—why didn’t they take the Eagles to Mordor in the first place and skip the whole tumultuous journey?
There are a variety of answers to this question, most of which are presented by the Lord of the Rings trilogy itself. However, if we also take the events of The Rings of Power as canon, there’s another key reason that flying into Mordor on the backs of Eagles while carrying the One Ring would have been an absolutely terrible idea.
Sauron Would Have Been On The Lookout For Eagles In The Lord Of The Rings
In The Rings of Power season 3, Sauron watches in silent rage as Galadriel and Celeborn escape on the back of Landroval, the prince of the Great Eagles. Of course, Sauron was no stranger to the Eagles. After all, these great creatures were sent to Middle-earth by the Valar in the First Age to keep an eye on Morgoth. Still, the Dark Lord would also have known that the Eagles don’t appear and lend support to just anyone. They are proud, majestic beings that exist quite outside the conflicts of Elves and Men.
It could therefore be argued that Sauron wouldn’t expect the Eagles to interfere with his work in The Lord of the Rings, making them a potentially valuable means of entering Mordor. However, if he had already seen Galadriel escape on an Eagle in the Second Age, there’s every reason to think Sauron would have been on high alert regarding these beings for the rest of his existence. By taking Galadriel to freedom, the Eagles bested the Dark Lord, and he wouldn’t forget it.
Rings Of Power Subtly Points Out Even More Reasons Why The Eagle Plan Wouldn’t Work
Even if we don’t consider Sauron’s run-in with the Eagles at Gundabad as canon, this commonly debated Lord of the Rings detail isn’t the plot hole people claim it is. The whole point of the Fellowship’s mission is subtlety. Sauron doesn’t expect anyone to try to destroy his One Ring rather than keep it for themselves, and he certainly doesn’t expect two hobbits to sneak into Mordor. A dramatic entrance on Eagles is more what the Dark Lord would have been looking for, and he would have sent the Fell Beasts to meet them immediately.
Rings of Power casually draws attention to this as well. When Galadriel, Arondir, and Marnûkh (who clearly parallel Frodo, Sam, and Gollum) make their plan to infiltrate Gundabad, Arondir states that they should show up with an army. Galadriel reminds him that subtlety is the way to go, noting that they would be best relying on “fellowship” rather than the sort of force the enemy would expect. The fact that this is later followed up by an escape on Eagles solidifies the parallels. The goal is and always has been a stealthy approach and a dramatic getaway.
https://static0.srcdn.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/the-lord-of-the-rings-the-return-of-the-king_466051-1.jpg?w=1600&h=900&fit=crop
https://screenrant.com/lotr-rings-of-power-eagles-plot-hole-explanation/
Angel Shaw
Almontather Rassoul




