‘9-1-1’ Is Officially Switching Protagonists, but There’s a Big Problem



[

Editor’s Note: The following contains spoilers for 9-1-1 Season 10, Episode 6.9-1-1 is just six episodes into its tenth season, but the show already just aired its mid-season finale. Any network procedural fan knows it’s standard for each main character to get a couple solo storylines during a shorter half-season like this, except for the show’s leads – which, since the beginning of 9-1-1, were Athena (Angela Bassett) and Bobby (Peter Krause). Since Bobby’s death, Athena has been 9-1-1‘s main lead, while the other characters each get a significant storyline every few episodes. Buck (Oliver Stark), however, has been getting more storylines than everyone else this season.

9-1-1 continues to go in circles with Buck’s character in Season 10, making him regress to the point of impulsively giving up the child he chose to foster instead of actually working through his trauma and self-worth issues. Five episodes have been dedicated to the Theo (Lincoln and Theodore Sykes) storyline this season, and every Buck and Eddie (Ryan Guzman) storyline this season has been about Theo. The latter wouldn’t necessarily be a problem, except that 9-1-1 is still giving Buck way too much focus without real growth, while unfairly relegating Eddie to the supporting role.

‘9-1-1’s Mid-Season 10 Finale Once Again Pivots Eddie’s Storyline to Buck

After spending pretty much all of his non-work screen time this season supporting Buck, Eddie got to make a bold move in last week’s episode when he chose to foster Theo. Even knowing that Buck would take this as a personal slight, Eddie prioritized the needs of Theo over the second most important relationship in his life – barring that with Christopher (Gavin McHugh), who cares deeply about Theo and even wrote Buck an angry letter for giving him up. 9-1-1 set up something compelling here, where viewers could see how Eddie adjusted to raising a second child, and how he’s been feeling about this entire situation. This was the perfect opportunity to get a rare insight into Eddie’s emotions, and to see the pain that Buck’s cruel remarks caused him.

Instead, Eddie only gets a little bit of focus in the mid-season finale. 9-1-1 finally delivers the long-anticipated first scene between Eddie and Maddie (Jennifer Love Hewitt), but the whole scene sees Maddie treating Eddie coldly and accusing him of fostering Theo to teach Buck a lesson. Maddie hasn’t been afraid to call Buck out in the past, like when he hurt Eddie’s ankle in “Buck, Bothered and Bewildered.” Here, though, she takes his side when Eddie isn’t even acting against him, and everyone from the 118 except for Ravi (Anirudh Pisharody) also backs Buck up. Eddie doesn’t get to talk about his feelings or his new role as a foster parent at all, and he instead oddly emphasizes the apparent importance of Buck’s role as Theo’s biological parent.

‘9-1-1’ Is Still Taking Eddie Diaz for Granted – and Ruining Buck and Eddie in the Process

The Buck and Eddie pairing became so beloved by fans because of their deep friendship and care for each other. They always supported each other through the toughest moments and showed up for each other – until now. Eddie tried to give Buck helpful and honest advice earlier this season, but Buck just lashed out at him. Eddie later stepped up and did something really thoughtful to help both Buck and Theo, and Buck blew up at him again. Instead of having each other’s backs like they promised they would before they even became friends, Eddie’s been consistently monitoring Buck’s back, while Buck can’t so much as be bothered to turn around and look at him. Everyone this season is coddling Buck except for Eddie, but Eddie’s still been exceptionally gentle with him, refusing to even accept his lackluster apology without also unfairly blaming himself.

Becoming a foster parent has the potential to be an amazing storyline for Eddie, but not in the way 9-1-1 is currently setting it up, where Eddie is just a stand-in parent for Theo until Buck is ready to take him back. 9-1-1 should focus on Eddie’s journey of parenting a second child, as well as the memories that this will inevitably bring up for him from Christopher’s childhood. Then, either Theo needs to stay with Eddie, or Buck and Eddie need to find a solution that works for them – because it would do Eddie a tremendous disservice to have him simply give Theo back to Buck after choosing to parent him. Considering the show has neglected Eddie’s storyline all season, it’s about time that he gets something more than just the crumbs of a storyline from Buck.

9-1-1 will return to ABC on Thursday, January 7 at 8:00 P.M. EST.

https://static0.colliderimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/buddie.jpg?w=1600&h=900&fit=crop
https://collider.com/9-1-1-season-10-midseason-finale-buck-eddie-problem/


Jennie Richardson
Almontather Rassoul

Latest articles

spot_imgspot_img

Related articles

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

spot_imgspot_img