Why you can trust TechRadar
We spend hours testing every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about how we test.
Mild spoilers follow for Doctor Who season 2 episode 1.
Doctor Who is, in many ways, the ultimate comfort food for sci-fi fanatics. There are times when the iconic British TV show will surprise you with its storytelling, character evolution, and/or thematic exploration. By and large, though, you know what you’re going to get with Gallifrey’s greatest export: a mostly fun-filled romp across time and space.
For better or worse, that’s a well-established formula that Doctor Who season 2 (or, for those of us who’ve watched it since its 2005 revival, Doctor Who season 15) doesn’t tamper with. This season’s opening chapter, titled ‘The Robot Revolution’, isn’t as narratively revolutionary as its name suggests. Still, while season 2’s premiere is predictable in its make-up, I largely had fun with what its 46-minute opener had to offer.
Paranoid android
Season 2 opens with the titular Time Lord (Ncuti Gatwa) racing to find Belinda ‘Bel’ Chandra (Varada Sethu), a London-based nurse, for unknown reasons.
Unfortunately, no sooner does The Doctor track her down at her home, he can only watch as Bel is whisked away by a group of menacing robots – who, for reasons that’ll become clear, claim she’s their planet’s Queen – to their home world.
Long story short: Bel is taken to a planet where everything is bizarrely named after her. That includes the world’s moniker (Miss Belinda Chandra-1), its race of humans (Belinda Chandra-kind), and its main city (Belinda Chandra-Ville).
Bel’s ties to a world that she has no recollection of are the least of her worries. Indeed, she’s been kidnapped to marry this world’s de-factor ruler and be fully assimilated as a human-robot hybrid not like classic Whovian villains The Cybermen (more on this comparison later). So much for a peaceful evening.
Hope is at hand, though. The Doctor has not only infiltrated Miss Belinda Chandra-1, but also teamed up with a group of human freedom fighters looking to overthrow their android oppressors. Cue a typically audacious rescue mission to save Bel and work out what’s actually going on.
For those who recognize Sethu’s Bel but can’t quite place her, allow me to help: Sethu also played Mundy Flynn in ‘Boom’, which was arguably season 1/season 14’s best episode. She also appeared in season 1 of Andor, FYI, and will do so again in Andor season 2, which arrives on Disney+ later this month.
But I digress. Unlike Peter Capaldi and Karen Gillan’s supporting roles in season 4 episode ‘The Fires of Pompeii’ before they secured central roles in later seasons, Sethu’s casting as Bel is deliberate.
Season 2 doesn’t hide the fact that Bel and Mundy are related. Indeed, The Doctor confirms as much during an expository sequence where discussing a so-called Time Fracture that’s a temporal border issue between Miss Belindra Chandra-1 and planet Earth. Continuity in a 70-year-old-plus TV series can be difficult to maintain, so cast additions like this – where an actor can play two versions of the same character – in any project is most welcome.
I’m pleased that loose plot threads from the show’s first season on Disney+ haven’t been fully discarded
As Doctor Who season 2’s first trailer teased, its big mystery isn’t just centered on Bel. It’s also directly linked to the overarching narrative involving Gatwa’s 15th Doctor that, as long as Gatwa is in for the long haul, should run for multiple seasons and, hopefully at some point, explain who or what the returning Mrs Flood is.
This isn’t a novel creative and storytelling approach for Doctor Who. Other multi-season stories, such as those involving Matt Smith and Jodie Foster’s iterations, have been structured similarly with their breadcrumb trail narratives that eventually lead to a grand reveal towards the end of each Doctor’s existence.
Nevertheless, I’m pleased that loose plot threads from the show’s first season on Disney+ haven’t been fully discarded with the introduction of The Doctor’s latest companion. Instead, it appears season 2 will build on the foundations laid by its predecessor and provide a semblance of storytelling pay-off amid this season’s primary directive; one that’ll see The Doctor attempt to take Bel home.
Companion pieces
To do so, he’ll have to take the long way home. No spoilers for the premiere’s ending and one of Doctor Who season 2’s big mysteries, but everyone’s favorite charismatic yet emotionally-damaged Time Lord will need more than a date and simple TARDIS handle-pull to get Bel safely back on terra firma.
The long journey home will provide ample opportunity to show Bel is a fantastic foil to the 15th Doctor, too.
The duo’s dynamic already has the air of a spicy yet respect-laden relationship. Bel has a charismatic, compassionate, and capricious personality to match that of her contemporary, and she’s not afraid to speak her mind (and put The Doctor in his place) if she disagrees with him.
The duo’s dynamic already has the air of a spicy yet respect-laden relationship
One episode in, the pair’s collaboration is more of a marriage of convenience than a bona fide friendship, but I expect that to change as this season progresses, and I can’t wait to see how this dynamic evolves as it does so.
Predictably, I have grievances about episode 1 of one of the best Disney+ shows‘ sophomore season. Aside from its villain-in-chief, who’s actually one of the more terrifying Doctor Who antagonists we’ve seen in a while, The Doctor and Bel’s robotic foes are largely unoriginal. In fact, I’d say, unique design notwithstanding, they’re an uninspired amalgam of two of the most notorious enemies in Doctor Who‘s rogue gallery – those being, the Daleks and Cybermen.
‘The Robot Revolution’ also moves at a break-neck pace. Episodes of Doctor Who are renowned for being breezy, but it feels like this one is particularly guilty of barrelling through its story without stopping to take a breath. That doesn’t allow its most pertinent story beats to have the emotional impact they require.
I was hesitant about including this for fear of being labeled ‘woke’, but I will applaud the season 2 premiere for tackling the difficult and uneasy topic of toxic masculinity in a somewhat child-friendly manner. This is a family-first show, after all. Nonetheless, it’s another brave and perfectly valid examination of present-day themes that aid the story and don’t, as some may claim, ruin Doctor Who as a visual and/or narrative experience.
My verdict
‘The Robot Revolution’ doesn’t break new ground for Doctor Who as a franchise, but there’s plenty that’ll entertain families and die-hard Whovians alike.
Visually, I’m eager to see season 2 maintain – and perhaps even build on – the trippy aesthetic that permeates its premiere. Story-wise, I hope it pushes the boundaries of the show and doesn’t befall the same fate as past seasons.
Indeed, its forthcoming animated episode suggests the former will occasionally happen but, even at this early stage, I’m praying that the pay-off from season 2’s big mystery is better than last season.
Otherwise, it’ll do the classic Whovian thing of promising much and delivering little. This is a series that explores all of time and space, after all, so let’s see some of that wibbly wobbly, timey-wimey magic return to the fore with increasing regularity, rather than being the exception to the norm.
Doctor Who season 2 premieres on Disney+ (internationally) and BBC One/BBC iPlayer (UK) on Saturday, April 12.
https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/49oTp3gNdTNK8AX892F73P-1200-80.jpg
Source link
tom.power@futurenet.com (Tom Power)
