Splash out or skimp? The pros and cons of choosing a more expensive VPN

With the new year barely underway, it’s a good time to take stock of your digital habits, especially when it comes to online privacy and security. A virtual private network (VPN) is one of the most effective tools to help keep your data safe, your real location hidden, and your browsing more private.

But with so many providers on the market offering plans at vastly different price points, the decision isn’t always straightforward. Some cost just a couple of dollars per month, while others charge a premium, and figuring out what you actually need can be confusing, especially for first-time users.

Is it worth splashing out on a premium VPN service, or can a budget-friendly option do the job just as well? Do you really get what you pay for when it comes to today’s best VPNs?

In this guide, we break down the pros and cons of choosing a more expensive VPN plan. Whether you’re upgrading or buying for the first time, we’ll help you decide which route offers the right balance of price, privacy, and performance.

First, you’re usually buying into a provider with more resources to invest in its infrastructure. That translates into better-performing VPN servers across more locations, higher speeds, and lower chances of congestion. Many of the top-tier services also maintain large fleets of physical rather than virtual servers, which can provide a stronger foundation for both performance and privacy.

Security is another area where price often reflects value. Advanced encryption standards, secure VPN protocols, and independently audited no-logs policies all require serious investment. Some providers also run active bug bounty programs and maintain in-house research teams to stay ahead of emerging threats.

Premium plans often bundle in bonus tools, too. Features like ad and tracker blockers, encrypted cloud storage, and built-in password managers are more common at the higher end of the market. These extras are often deeply integrated into the app, which can make for a smoother experience than juggling multiple standalone tools. While not everyone will need these extras, they can be a convenient and cost-effective way to bolster your overall security stack.

Pricier VPNs tend to offer polished apps across more platforms, more frequent updates, and better customer support. If you want a set-and-forget solution with minimal hassle, these qualities matter.

Finally, another factor to consider is longevity. VPNs with more expensive plans are often from providers with a long track record, consistent app updates, and established trust within the industry. This can offer added peace of mind for users looking to stick with a single provider long-term, especially as privacy laws and digital threats continue to evolve each year.

In short, a more expensive VPN is often the right choice for those who want to fully commit to their digital security and enjoy a broader range of advanced features.

It’s also easy to end up overpaying for features you won’t use. While things like password managers and encrypted cloud storage are great on paper, not everyone needs them. If you already use standalone tools for these tasks, a bundled solution may just duplicate what you have. Similarly, not all users need access to dozens of server locations or advanced protocol options.

Another issue is commitment risk. If you sign up for a more expensive plan and later decide it’s not right for you, you could be stuck with it, especially if the money-back guarantee window has passed. This can be particularly frustrating for newer VPN users who are still figuring out what they actually need.

It’s also worth remembering that premium VPNs can sometimes limit flexibility. Some high-end providers offer fewer simultaneous connections or restrict certain features to top-tier plans. If you share your VPN with family or want coverage across multiple devices, these limits can be frustrating, especially when cheap VPNs often allow unlimited connections for less money.

Then there’s the fact that paying more doesn’t always mean better performance. Some pricier VPNs lag behind budget rivals when it comes to connection speeds, streaming access, or app stability. Others may focus heavily on privacy but skip out on modern UI features or advanced customization options. Some even lack niche but helpful extras like split tunneling, dedicated IPs, or multi-hop routing, which may be available in cheaper plans or only on select devices.

Ultimately, spending more can lead to a better experience, but it also comes with trade-offs. If you’re new to VPNs or unsure how often you’ll use one, a cheaper plan might make more sense. And thankfully, there are budget VPNs, like Surfshark, that still deliver outstanding value without the high price tag.