Xiaomi Buds 5: Two-minute review
Like most Chinese tech companies, Xiaomi’s product portfolio runs the gamut from smartphones and fitness trackers to tablets, air fryers, electric scooters and massage guns, and while you may know the company for a few of those gadgets, headphones may not be one of them. And it’s true that the company has yet to feature in our roundup of the best earbuds we’ve tested, although we keep checking with reviews just like these.
So while the likes of the Xiaomi 14 and Xiaomi 14 Ultra smartphones may be stealing headlines and winning hearts (we gave both 4.5/5), the Xiaomi Buds 5 have more of an uphill battle in order to win listeners over. And as you’ll soon find out, the buds’ favorite direction is actually ‘down’.
The Xiaomi Buds 5 are new headphones that are some of Xiaomi’s higher-end audio offerings, but still certainly fall into the ‘best cheap headphones‘ category, bumping up against many options from rival audio brands as well as from market stalwarts.
There’s a lot to like with the Xiaomi Buds 5, but enough to dislike that you may not want to put up with the good parts.
My main issue, which plagued testing from the day I started until the day I finished, was the fit of these earbuds. Without any silicone tip, or much of an arch in the design to hook them into your ear, the Buds 5 just refuse to stay in place. They’ll start to slip if you so much as walk, and a head shake or jump will see them tumble from place. I found myself repeatedly pushing them back into my ear if I had to go on walks with them in.
I thought the issue was down to my ear shape but (after heavy sanitization) I made a few other people test them out too. They all commented, unprovoked, that the buds felt very loose. A decent fit in a design that doesn’t use ear tips to achieve a seal something Apple‘s worked on extensively for its AirPods 4 rollout, and Xiaomi could learn a little for the Cupertino giant here.
So you’re only going to be able to enjoy your music if you’re sitting still, or doing gentle activities like chopping veg for dinner or vacuuming your apartment. But then you’re going to have to contend with an app that I found to be quite buggy.
Many times during testing, I’d pop the buds in my ears only to find that some key features weren’t working. I found that the buds needed to be manually reconnected in the app for these features to work, with ANC and my custom equalizer only enabled after this. I can’t imagine that this is an intentional feature, so I can only presume that it’s a bug (hopefully, one that an update will fix).
These are two major issues but there are a few things that I’d consider significant ‘cons’ on better earbuds: the noise cancellation, battery life and call quality are all middling to poor.
So with that all in mind, why have I given the Xiaomi Buds 5 a fairly reasonable score? Well, it’s largely down to the sound quality: they have a really distinctive and appealing audio balance that leans heavily on bass without losing trebles and mids. It’s zealous, it’s punchy and it’s oh-so likeable! Music is high-quality, thanks to support for a few big codecs, and Harman Kardon tuning helps you appreciate your songs in a roaring and bordering on warm balance. That’s if you can enjoy your music before the buds fall from your ears!
A few more features win the Xiaomi Buds 5 points too, including an audio-recording feature that you can enable straight from your ears, really convenient gesture controls, and a svelte and lightweight carry case. Honestly, the poor app and irritating fit let these otherwise promising earbuds down.
Xiaomi Buds 5 review: Price and release date
- Unveiled in September 2024
- Sells for £69.99 (roughly $90, AU$140)
- On sale in Europe for now
The Xiaomi Buds 5 were announced in late September 2024, alongside the Mi Smart Band 9 and a range of smart-home products.
You can pick up the buds for £69.99 (roughly $90, AU$140) which makes these contenders for our round-up of the best cheap earbuds. Based on precedent, Xiaomi could release a pricier Pro version down the line, and its full audio range extends from pricier open-ear sports buds to some staggeringly cheap buds under its Redmi sub-brand.
At that price you’d be comparing these to a few rivals from other mobile brands including the CMF Buds Pro 2 and OnePlus Buds Nord 3 Pro, as well as the fantastic Sony WF-C510 and Earfun Air Pro 4.
There’s no news on a release outside Europe just yet and Xiaomi doesn’t release much of its tech in the US, but in Australia we could well see it go on sale based on precedent.
Xiaomi Buds 5 review: Specs
| Drivers | 11mm |
| Active noise cancellation | Yes |
| Battery life | 6.5 hours (buds) 39 hours (case) |
| Weight | 45g |
| Connectivity | Bluetooth 5.4 |
| Frequency range | 16Hz – 40kHz |
| Waterproofing | NA |
Xiaomi Buds 5 review: Features
- Middling battery life and ANC performance
- Offers novel audio recording feature
- App has some bugs
The Buds 5 do offer active noise cancellation, but it’s nothing to write home about. There are two modes: Balanced and Deep, with an adaptive mode that’ll toggle between the two depending on your environment, but neither are particularly hardcore. They’ll take the edge off of annoying background noises but not muffle them in any significant way, and the lack of passive noise isolation from the buds’ design doesn’t help either.
The battery life of the buds isn’t fantastic, clocking in at 6.5 hours with ANC turned off according to Xiaomi. The company doesn’t provide a figure for listening time with it turned on, but I got the buds to last a touch over 5 hours with ANC deployed. The case will keeping ticking for a lot longer though, with 39 hours of playback when ANC is off according to Xiaomi. Based on my aforementioned figures, I’d estimate that you’d get 30 hours with ANC on.
For the rest of the features we need to jump into the app, but there’s a problem here. The Xiaomi Earbuds app had a big issue which affected the use of many of the Buds 5 features, and I can’t tell if it’s an intentional one or a bug.
Every time I put the earbuds in my ears, the app wouldn’t automatically realize that they were connected – I’d have to load it up and press ‘connect’. Before I did this, features including ANC control and the ability to tweak settings wouldn’t work, and it was an irritating extra step every time I wanted to listen to music. Other options don’t do it; I can’t imagine why it would be desirable.
Some of the features offered by the buds are standard ones that we’ve come to expect in wireless earbuds (not that all rivals offer them, so their presence in the Xiaomi Buds are welcome). These include changing the gesture controls, toggling wear detection, setting up dual-device connectivity, checking the buds’ battery life, changing ANC modes and finding the buds if you’ve misplaced them.
The Xiaomi Earbuds app offers an equalizer, albeit one hidden away in the Audio Effects menu, as well as a few simple presets like Enhance Voice or Decrease Bass. I found myself using the Harman AudioEFX preset mostly, which I’ll explore in more detail later on.
You can also use Audio Effects to turn on ‘Dimensional Audio’, which is presumably Xiaomi’s answer to Spatial Audio, a feature that plenty of earbuds offer in order to make music sound like it’s surrounding you. However, this feature in the Buds 5 transports you to one space in particular: the cellar underneath a nightclub bar. It seems to simply slather on oceans of artificial reverb, as though you’re hearing tunes through several layers of brick, making music sound awful. Avoid!
One novel feature the Xiaomi Buds 5 offer is an audio-recording feature. While most earbuds will do this, as they’ll replace the audio input of your phone while connected, Xiaomi bakes this feature into the app, and also lets you enable it as a gesture control for the buds.
It’s not a feature that everyone will find hugely useful, but I can see some finding it handy in certain situations. I found it convenient as a way to leave myself voice memos without having to find a pen and paper or my smartphone, and I see it being handy for anyone who likes hands-free note-taking like this. Just bear in mind the laws where you live regarding recording people without their consent, something the app does remind you about.
Xiaomi Buds 5 review: Design
- Earbuds keep slipping out
- Touch controls on the bud
- Lightweight carry case
Unlike many of its rivals and contemporaries, Xiaomi hasn’t put a silicon tip of the Buds 5. It didn’t for its predecessors, saving that for the Pro equivalents. It’s a shame because my biggest gripe with the earbuds is that they had trouble staying in my ears, a problem eartips would likely fix.
This problem didn’t occur if I was seated or keeping my head relatively static, but when walking (or doing any other kind of movement) the Buds 5 would quickly start to slip – I’d have to constantly be re-adjusting the fit and pushing the buds back into my ears.
Not only was this indescribably irritating, but buds that are half out the ear aren’t delivering on their full sonic potential, and also fall foul of sensitive wear detection too. This issue ruled me out form using the buds in the gym, and I stopped using them when cooking too as I didn’t want to push them back into my ears with messy hands – or have them fall into the pot.
Each bud has a small button on the stem that you can squeeze for various controls: single, double, triple and long presses for different functions. It takes quite a hearty press to trigger the function but a light ‘click’ lets you know that your action was successful.
The buds are relatively light, weighing 4.2g each. They have an IP54 protection which means they’re safe from splashes of water and ingress of dust, but immersion in water will wreck them.
The Buds 5 come in a shiny plastic chrome-looking case, which I think is pretty neat-looking even though the reflections make taking review pictures an absolute nightmare!
Opening this clam-shell case reveals the entirety of the buds, unlike many other cases which hide the stems in the body – because of this I found it really easy to remove the buds when I wasn’t paying attention, as the process was less fiddly than almost all rivals on the market.
The case weighs 36.6g and comes with a USB-C port for charging, and not a lot else. You can pick up the buds in silver, white and black, and your choice affects the case and the buds.
Xiaomi Buds 5 review: Sound quality
- Great audio for price
- Tuning from Harman Kardon
- Support for good list of codices
The Xiaomi Buds 5 have 11mm drivers and tick quite a few audiophile boxes. These include support for a range of codecs including AAC, SBC, LC3, aptX Lossless and aptX Adaptive, connectivity using Bluetooth 5.4, and support for Bluetooth Low Energy. They also have an audio balance tuned by Harman Kardon, continuing a partnership between Xiaomi and the audio specialists which has also extended to its smartphones and speakers.
When I first started listening to the Xiaomi Buds 5, I was surprised just how much bass they offered for in-ear buds, and of all the buds I’ve tested recently they’re second only to Nothing’s recent audio offerings in terms of sheer thump-power (that’s the technical term).
In the default audio balance, the Harman AudioEFX, here’s a distinctive focus on lower-focus instruments and pitches, making for a balance so warm that you’d think Xiaomi had used some tech from one of its kitchen gadgets. I can see some people loving the mix, and others really not getting on with it, but the other presets can balance the sound a little better.
Whether you like the balance or don’t, it’s hard to deny that the quality is great for the price; I don’t notice significant peaking or distortion, and the treble and mid were still palpable in the mix even if they weren’t the priority. Music had a level of energy that I’ve longed for in other similarly-priced rivals that I’ve tested.
Marring the otherwise-great audio quality is the bud fit issue that I mentioned before – music sounds great when the buds are sitting comfortably in your ears, but as soon as they begin to slip out you’ll be losing that music magic.
As mentioned earlier there’s an equalizer mode and I see most people relying on the presets due to the way they’re laid out in the app. These largely deliver on the promise in the title: increased bass, focus on voice and so on, with the default mode delivering the most nuanced mix.
Xiaomi Buds 5 review: Value
- Better audio than you’d expect for the price
- Perhaps hold out for a Pro model
When I first started testing the Xiaomi Buds 5 I didn’t know the exact price they’d launch for, and the cost that I guessed they’d retail for ended up being a slight amount more than the actual price. That is to say, I thought the earbuds would cost more than they do.
That’s mainly down to the audio chops: between the sound quality, specs list and Harman Kardon tuning, Xiaomi seems to have hit exactly what it aimed at, whether or not it’ll be to everyone’s specific tastes. You’re also getting all the features you’d expect for earbuds at this price and they mostly seem to work well.
The one thing I should flag though is the prospect of Pro buds: in the past Xiaomi’s Pro options have had silicon tips, unlike the standard models, and these would fit my ear fit issues. I can’t wholeheartedly recommend the Buds 5 if a reasonably-priced Buds 5 Pro could be around the corner.
Should I buy the Xiaomi Buds 5?
| Attributes | Notes | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Features | A middling list of features including average ANC and battery life. | 3.5/5 |
| Design | A poor in-ear fit and no IP rating equal a low score. | 3.3/5 |
| Sound quality | The buds sound great for the price, with an emphasis on bass. | 4/5 |
| Value | The buds sound good for the price even though they have issues. | 3.5/5 |
Buy them if…
Don’t buy them if…
Xiaomi Buds 5 review: Also consider
| Xiaomi Buds 5 | Sony WF-C510 | Earfun Air Pro 4 | CMF Buds Pro 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | £69.99 (roughly $90, AU$140) | $59.99 / £54.99 / AU$109 | $89.99 / £79.99 / Approx. AU$140 | $119 / £99 / AU$199 |
| Drivers | 11mm | 6mm | 10mm | 11mm + 6mm |
| Active noise cancellation | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Battery life | Buds: 6.5 hours / Case: 39 hours | Buds: 11 hours / Case: 11 hours | Buds: 7.5 hours (11 hours without ANC). Case: 35 hours (52 hours without ANC).) | 11 hours (buds) 43 hours (case) |
| Weight | 3.6g | 4.6g | 5g | 4.9g |
| Connectivity | Bluetooth 5.4 | Bluetooth 5.3 | Bluetooth 5.4 | Bluetooth 5.3 |
| Frequency range | 16Hz – 40kHz | 20Hz – 20,000Hz | 2.402Ghz – 2.480GHz | 20Hz – 20kHz |
| Waterproofing | NA | IPX4 | IPX5 | IP55 |
How I tested the Xiaomi Buds 5
- Tested for two weeks
- Tested at home, in the office and on trips
The Xiaomi Buds 5 enjoyed a testing period of two weeks, though I used the buds for longer than that while I was writing the review itself. They were mainly connected to my Android phone though I paired them to a few other devices, including an iPad and Windows laptop.
Testing was mostly done at home or in my office but I also used the earbuds on a few walks and on public transport. I mostly listened to music using Spotify but also listened to spoken word, played games and watched TV shows on Netflix.
I’ve tested tech for TechRadar for over 5 years now and that includes countless Xiaomi devices and rival budget earbuds. I tested all of the Buds 5’s close contemporary rivals.
- First reviewed in September 2024
https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/PGJTZ8MJGKypV3gQuxfo3m-1200-80.jpg
Source link
tom.bedford@futurenet.com (Tom Bedford)
