[
Come November, it seems like the same Thanksgiving episodes circulate on every streaming list. They’re the Friends holiday flashbacks, the parade mishaps of Seinfeld, the tofurkey served by Mrs. Kim on Gilmore Girls. If you’ve seen one “best Thanksgiving TV” list, you’ve seen them all. And sure, those episodes earned their spot, but the holiday is a pressure cooker for good TV. One table, too much wine, friends and relatives who know exactly which buttons to push, and a meal no one can escape.
There are plenty of episodes out there celebrating the day spent stuffing faces and cringing at historical re-tellings of Pilgrims and Native Americans getting along. But for every episode that makes the annual rotation, there’s one just as good that never gets its due. In fact, the Thanksgiving TV canon runs deeper than most people realize. These are the ones worth adding to your queue.
9
“The Gang Squashes Their Beefs”
‘It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’ (2005–Present)
After nine seasons of burning bridges across Philadelphia, the It’s Always Sunny gang decides to use Thanksgiving dinner to make peace with everyone they’ve wronged. The motivation isn’t guilt — it’s that they’ve run out of places to go. Dennis (Glenn Howerton) tallies up the bars, restaurants, and entire neighborhoods they’ve been banned from, and the only solution anyone can come up with is inviting the McPoyles, the Waitress (Mary Elizabeth Ellis), Liam (Jimmi Simpson), and other recurring casualties of the Gang’s sociopathy to Mac (Rob Mac) and Dennis’ apartment for a reconciliation feast. The dinner devolves almost immediately.
Every attempt at an apology turns into a new argument. The food fight starts early, and the episode ends with the Gang barricading their guests inside the apartment, drilling the door shut, and leaving while the place catches fire. It’s the season finale, and it works as a perfect inversion of what a Thanksgiving episode is supposed to do. Where most shows use the holiday to bring people together, It’s Always Sunny uses it to prove that some people are fundamentally incapable of change, and it’s funnier for being honest about it.
8
“Turkey in a Can”
‘Bob’s Burgers’ (2011–Present)
Bob Belcher (H. Jon Benjamin) takes his Thanksgiving turkey extremely seriously, so when his carefully brined bird keeps ending up in the toilet, he treats it as a crime scene. The kids all have motives (mostly to mess with Bob), though Linda (John Roberts) is too cheerful to be innocent, and Gayle’s (Megan Mullally) cats are lurking around with unclear intentions. Every time Bob replaces the turkey, it winds up back in the toilet. He goes through three birds before the episode is over.
The payoff is both absurd and oddly sweet: Bob has been sleepwalking and putting the turkey in the toilet himself because he’s dreaming about potty-training a young Tina (Dan Mintz). It’s the kind of reveal that could only work on Bob’s Burgers, where the emotional logic is always a little sideways but completely sincere. The Belchers’ Thanksgiving episodes are a tradition unto themselves at this point, but “Turkey in a Can” is one of the best, a holiday mystery that wraps up with Bob coming to terms with his kids growing up.
7
“Planes, Shanes and Automobiles”
‘Ghosts’ (2021–Present)
By Season 5, Ghosts has gotten really good at finding new ways to strand Sam (Rose McIver) between the living and the dead. “Planes, Shanes and Automobiles” sends her on a book tour road trip with ghost Pete (Richie Moriarty) riding along, and the two of them get on each other’s nerves almost immediately. When an airline strike threatens to strand them and wreck their Thanksgiving plans, Pete channels his inner John Candy.
Back at Woodstone, the ghosts are fed up with Jay’s (Utkarsh Ambudkar) inability to meet their demands while Sam is gone, so they recruit Kyle (Ben Feldman), the only other living person who can see them. Kyle immediately one-ups Jay at ghost-sitting, and the rivalry between them is a low-key highlight of the whole season. The episode ends with Kyle joining the Arondekars’ first Thanksgiving at Woodstone, and the found-family energy of that final scene is the kind of thing Ghosts has always done well, even when the rest of the TV landscape has moved on from network sitcoms.
6
“I Went to Market”
‘Succession’ (2018–2023)
Five episodes in, Succession was still finding its legs, and then the Roys sat down for Thanksgiving dinner. Logan (Brian Cox) hosts at his penthouse, and the guest list alone is a disaster waiting to happen: his estranged brother Ewan (James Cromwell) shows up from Canada, Kendall (Jeremy Strong) is quietly building a vote of no confidence, Connor (Alan Ruck) brings Willa (Justine Lupe) and raises eyebrows across the table, and Tom (Matthew Macfayden) is starting to realize what he’s actually signed up for. Everyone at this dinner has an agenda, and the holiday gives them just enough cover to pretend they don’t.
The episode’s title comes from a children’s memory game the family plays after dinner, and it’s during this game that Logan, showing signs of cognitive decline from his stroke, strikes his grandson Iverson (Quentin Morales). It’s a moment that reframes everything that came before it. The rest of this list skews funny, messy, heartfelt. This one is none of those things, and it’s here anyway, because Thanksgiving isn’t always sweet. Some families weaponize the dinner table, and the Roys do it better than anyone on television.
COLLIDERInteractive
Five Doors
Franchises/Quizzes/Your Universe
5
“Homo for the Holidays”
‘Will & Grace’ (1998–2020)
This one aired on Thanksgiving night in 1999, and Sean Hayes absolutely demolished it. Jack’s (Hayes) mom Judith (Veronica Cartwright) comes to Will (Eric McCormack) and Grace’s (Debra Messing) apartment for the holiday, and Will and Grace are stunned to realize she has no idea her son is gay. Jack has been telling her that he and Grace used to date. Karen (Megan Mullally) jumps in, claiming to be Jack’s current girlfriend, and the deception snowballs from there until Jack’s friends push him to tell his mother the truth. For a show that wore its queerness proudly from the pilot, the fact that Jack had never come out to his own mother added real weight.
Hayes plays the scene where he finally tells her with the kind of vulnerability he didn’t always get to show on the series, and it makes the comedy around it hit differently. The episode won the series a special Thanksgiving timeslot and helped cement Will & Grace‘s second season as the one that earned its Outstanding Comedy Emmy.
4
“Pilgrim Rick”
‘This Is Us’ (2016–2022)
The Pearson family Thanksgiving episodes of This Is Us became a whole thing over six seasons, but the first one is where the template was set. Jack (Milo Ventimiglia) and Rebecca (Mandy Moore) are driving the kids to her parents’ house when things go sideways, and they end up at a run-down motel called the Pinewood Lodge. The manager wears a pilgrim hat and calls himself “Pilgrim Rick.” Jack, being Jack, puts on the hat, declares himself the new Pilgrim Rick, and turns a busted Thanksgiving into a family tradition that the Pearson kids carry into adulthood.
In the present-day timeline, that tradition is still going on, but the holiday takes a devastating turn when Randall (Sterling K. Brown) discovers that Rebecca knew about his biological father and kept it from him for his entire life. He confronts her during the family’s yarn game, and the scene is a gut punch. The genius of “Pilgrim Rick” is how it holds both things at once: the warmth of a family building something out of nothing and the fractures that were always underneath.
3
“The One with the Rumor”
‘Friends’ (1994–2004)
When this episode aired in November 2001, Brad Pitt and Jennifer Aniston were married, which turned a solid Friends Thanksgiving into a full-on pop culture event. Pitt plays Will Colbert, a formerly overweight high school classmate of Ross (David Schwimmer) and Monica (Courteney Cox) who shows up to Thanksgiving dinner looking like, well, Brad Pitt. The twist: Will co-founded the “I Hate Rachel Green Club” with Ross back in the day, and he has not moved on.
The episode’s best gag is the slow reveal that Ross’ grudge against Rachel was organized enough to have its own club, its own membership, and its own rumor campaign. Although Joey (Matt LeBlanc) eating an entire turkey by himself while wearing Phoebe’s (Lisa Kudrow) maternity pants is a great subplot. The real-life casting adds a weird meta layer that makes the whole thing funnier in retrospect, and it earned Pitt an Emmy nomination for Outstanding Guest Actor in a Comedy Series.
2
“Three Turkeys”
‘Modern Family’ (2009–2020)
Modern Family spent eleven seasons proving that the funniest version of family dysfunction is the kind where everyone genuinely means well. Phil (Ty Burrell) dreams too hard, Claire (Julie Bowen) controls too much, Jay (Ed O’Neill) avoids feelings, Gloria (Sofía Vergara) pulls them out of him like teeth, and every week, the confessional interviews let them explain exactly why they were right before the episode proved them wrong. “Three Turkeys” takes all of that and “stuffs it” into one house in one afternoon.
Phil and Luke (Nolan Gould) take over Thanksgiving dinner. Claire lets them, and also secretly cooks a backup turkey, because trusting Phil with a major holiday meal is a bridge too far. Jay and Gloria, meanwhile, fake a trip to Colombia just to get out of going. It’s the kind of episode where every character has a totally reasonable plan that falls apart the second it touches anyone else’s totally reasonable plan. But the Thanksgiving setting makes everything tighter than a regular episode, because nobody can leave and dinner is on a deadline.
1
“Parents”
‘New Girl’ (2011–2018)
Casting Jamie Lee Curtis and Rob Reiner as Jess’ (Zooey Deschanel) divorced parents was one of the best moves New Girl ever made, and this episode is their debut. Jess invites her mom Joan and dad Bob to the loft for Thanksgiving dinner, planning separate meals so they don’t have to see each other. When they both show up at the same time, Jess pivots into full Parent Trap mode, enlisting Nick (Jake Johnson) and Cece (Hannah Simone) to help reunite them. The highlight here is how the rest of the friend group is roped into Jess’ childhood scheme.
Curtis and Johnson, basting a turkey together a bit too sexually, have an off-the-rails energy while Reiner and Deschanel share some quiet, grounded father-daughter scenes New Girl didn’t always make time for. And then there’s Schmidt (Max Greenfield) versus his cousin Big Schmidt (Rob Riggle), which turns Thanksgiving dinner into a physical competition nobody wanted. It’s a crowded episode, but New Girl‘s second season was the show at its most confident, and “Parents” holds all of it together.
https://static0.colliderimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/modern-family-three-turkeys-1.jpeg?w=1600&h=900&fit=crop
https://collider.com/thanksgiving-episodes-most-overlooked-ranked/
Jessica Toomer
Almontather Rassoul




