8 Dark Fantasy Books That Are Perfectly Written

It’s difficult enough for a dark fantasy book—or one belonging to any genre, for that matter—to be great. It’s an even rarer sight to find a dark fantasy masterpiece that’s perfectly written in virtually every sense that matters. Beautiful prose, stunning world-building, perfectly-constructed character work, and layered thematic explorations are all things that characterize all of the best-written works of dark fantasy in the history of literature.

Dark fantasy is all about blending traditional fantasy elements (like magic and mythical creatures) with macabre elements, flawed protagonists, and an air of dread that doesn’t leave until the pages stop turning. It’s not an easy genre to write perfectly, but authors of the stature of Joe Abercrombie and George R. R. Martin have managed over the years, making their work essential reading for all fans of the genre.

‘Between Two Fires’ (2012)

Image via Ace

Historical fiction is a genre that lends itself perfectly well to being accompanied by elements of dark fantasy, as Christopher Buehlman demonstrated flawlessly in 2012 with Between Two Fires. This horror novel is set during the Black Death, following a disgraced knight and a mysterious young girl who travel across France as the Devil and other fallen angels start a war with Heaven. It’s one of the best dark fantasy books of all time, and certainly one of the best of the 2010s.

Dealing with themes of reception and asking why God allows disasters like the Black Death to happen on Earth, Between Two Fires is as philosophically profound as it is irresistibly entertaining. Buehlman does a magnificent job of injecting humor and lyrical prose to the story without ever losing the overbearing sense of darkness that looms over the narrative, resulting in a fantasy experience that’s as viscerally dark as it is deeply moving.

‘The Book of the New Sun’ (1980–1983, 1987)

Image via Simon & Schuster

There are those who may argue that it’s more of a book series, but Gene Wolfe designed The Book of the New Sun as a single epic, sprawling novel told in four volumes and one coda. Part sci-fi (it’s actually easily one of the best sci-fi books of the last 50 years), part dark fantasy, this science fantasy masterpiece follows an apprentice torturer who falls in love with a prisoner and is exiled. He then journeys across a decaying future Earth in search of redemption.

It has long been praised as one of the greatest works of science fantasy of its time, a 1,600-page behemoth that won several major awards over the course of its volumes and coda. With stunning, almost surreal prose and some of the best use of unreliable narration that the genre has ever seen, it’s a brilliant literary puzzle that surprisingly invites multiple re-reads despite its daunting length.

‘The Last Unicorn’ (1968)

Image via Roc

Just like its movie adaptation is considered one of the greatest dark fantasy film masterpieces of all time, Peter S. Beagle‘s The Last Unicorn is likewise one of the greatest works of dark fantasy literature in history. Ranked as the fifth-best fantasy novel of all time by Locus Magazine subscribers in 1987, it may no longer occupy such a high spot in such a prestigious genre ranking, but it sure still deserves to be right up there among the greats. Its story follows a unicorn who believes she is the last of her kind and undertakes a quest to discover what has happened to the other unicorns.

It doesn’t feature any violence or sexuality, but it is arguably in no way a children’s novel. That’s because even though Beagle writes with a beautifully whimsical prose like he’s writing a traditional fairy tale, The Last Unicorn explores mature themes of mortality, regret, and the loss of innocence that are much likelier to resonate with older readers. In any case, it should be considered essential reading for all those who love classic dark fantasy.

‘The Blade Itself’ (2006)

Image via Gollancz

Joe Abercrombie’s The Blade Itself is the first chapter in the First Law Trilogy, which is likewise the first part of the overarching fantasy series of the same title. It happens to be the best of the bunch by a decent margin, following three main characters that are unknowingly drawn together by an ancient wizard as a war brews between the Union and the Northmen. Character-driven and fueled by an unexpectedly effective sense of humor, it’s masterful proof that dark fantasy doesn’t need to be devoid of laughter.

It’s not a comedy novel, however, but rather a grimdark gem characterized by moral ambiguity and thematic cynicism. It’s one of the best fantasy book masterpieces ever, following a set of morally grey characters with a level of psychological depth and complexity that you don’t often see in genres like this one. Brilliantly subversive and flawless in how it balances its three POVs, it’s dark fantasy at its modern best.

‘The Last Wish’ (1993)

Image via Orbit

In this day and age, the Witcher franchise needs no introduction; but it took several years for what started as a beloved book series in Poland to grow into the international pop-cultural sensation that it is today. In fact, the first Witcher book Andrzej Sapkowski ever wrote was 1992’s Sword of Destiny, which wasn’t translated into English until 2015. The second Witcher book Sapkowski wrote, which then became the first in the series’ chronology, was the short story collection The Last Wish, which was translated to English in 2007.

All these many years later, this short story collection is still widely remembered as the best book in the series. Subverting classic fairy tale tropes and exploring deep philosophical themes, Sapkowski masterfully deconstructs the dark fairy tale genre as a whole with a morally grey worldview. With the framing story of Geralt resting and recovering at the Temple of Melitel tying the disjointed flashbacks together, The Last Wish established an absolutely fascinating world with kinetic pacing and subtext-heavy dialogue.

‘Mistborn: The Final Empire’ (2006)

Image via Brandon Sanderson / Tor Books

All those tired of authors who have been promising certain fantasy novels for over a decade ought to take a look at Brandon Sanderson, one of the most immensely prolific and talented authors to ever grace the realm of speculative fiction. Sanderson is particularly masterful at writing fantasy, as proven by his Mistborn series, a cornerstone of the author’s Cosmere shared universe. The first chapter in the series, Mistborn: The Final Empire, is widely recognized as the best so far. Set during the rule of a tyrannical regime, it’s about a group of rebels trying to overthrow the Lord Ruler.

Indeed, it’s one of the best books of the 2000s, an absolutely legendary work of dark fantasy literature that’s perfectly written in virtually every way imaginable. The magic system is one of the most fascinating in the genre’s history, the structure is absolutely brilliant, and Sanderson’s use of foreshadowing makes re-reads pretty much obligatory at some point.

‘A Storm of Swords’ (2000)

Image via Bantam Spectra

Before it was Game of Thrones, the Song of Ice and Fire was a series of some of the greatest fantasy novels ever written. Of course, by now, the saga is perhaps best known for the fact that George R. R. Martin is over a decade overdue on delivering the penultimate chapter, but that doesn’t detract from the fact that these are some of the most perfectly-written fantasy books in history. It’s not an easy task to pick one’s favorite Song of Ice and Fire novel, but far more often than not, there’s one answer that’s guaranteed to come up for that question more frequently than all the others: A Storm of Swords, the third book in the series, following the brutal War of the Five Kings.

It’s an absolute behemoth of a book, the kind of dark fantasy masterpiece that only comes once in a generation. For one, it’s stunning just how well the book works as a pivotal point for the entire series, completely transforming the trajectory of the story, the political landscape of Westeros, and the fate of all of the main characters. Balancing explosive, non-stop pacing with impeccably nuanced and subtle character development is no easy task, so leave it to George R. R. Martin to write a dark fantasy epic this perfectly.

‘Divine Comedy’ (1321)

Image via Barnes & Noble

There are those who may argue that Dante Alighieri‘s narrative poem Divine Comedy, begun in 1308 and finished in 1321 (shortly before the Italian poet and philosopher’s death), is technically not a book; but it’s undeniably the foundational work of literary fantasy and the original dark fantasy masterpiece, so no list of this nature could ever possibly be complete without it. Even over seven centuries after its completion, it’s still a must-read for virtually anyone and everyone with the capacity to read—and that’s likely to still be the case seven centuries from now.

The historical significance of this absolute titan of European culture goes without saying, from its foundational view of the afterlife to its help in establishing the Tuscan language. Of course, comparing it to any modern work of fiction is silly, but it’s still easy to say that it’s one of the most perfectly-written works of literature in history. With its fusion of flawless mathematical symmetry, flawless emotional depth, and flawless world-building, it’s an obsessively precise masterpiece that anyone even slightly interested in the history of dark fantasy should read at least once in their lives.