Netflix’s New Remake Of Oscar-Winning Legal Drama Must Succeed At Its Hardest Task

Netflix’s remake of a classic Oscar-winning legal drama has the Herculean task of recreating one of the most popular scenes in cinematic history. The streaming giant has not only been able to adapt TV shows and movies from some of the biggest IPs, like League of Legends, The Witcher, and Devil May Cry, but it also has some decent legal drama offerings with the likes of Suits and The Lincoln Lawyer among its extensive catalog.

Reboots and remakes are now a dime a dozen, so it makes sense that Al Pacino’s 1979 film, …And Justice For All will be getting the same treatment. According to a report by Deadline, the Netflix TV series will hail from Sony Pictures Television and will be penned by Jeremy Miller and Dan Cohn. So far, no details about the cast or the exact storyline have been revealed. Like many remakes, the Netflix series has a difficult road ahead of it, particularly because …And Justice For All has one of the most iconic courtroom scenes.

At the end of …And Justice For All, Al Pacino’s character, Arthur Kirkland, finally snaps when he has to defend a judge who he not only hates, but isn’t actually innocent. During the first day of trial, Kirkland gives an impassioned speech before eventually snapping and announcing that the judge is guilty and begins yelling, “You’re out of order,” while pointing at everyone in the courtroom. The “You’re out of order” speech has become so iconic that it’s been parodied several times.

If Netflix does go ahead with the …And Justice For All remake, it needs to ensure that the recreation of the famous speech is as powerful as it was in the movie. Given how many times it’s been parodied, this won’t be something that’s easy to do, particularly because of the fine line between it being comedic and serious. The streamer has absolutely no choice but to include the infamous speech, and hopefully it will be as iconic as it was in the Pacino film.

And Justice For All Can Work Better As A TV Series Than As A Movie

…And Justice For All has been hailed as one of the greatest legal dramas in movie history, and for good reason. The classic film has a lot to say, from mental health to the failures of the justice system. Since …And Justice for All follows Arthur Kirkland, a lawyer navigating multiple cases and ethical dilemmas, it naturally creates the perfect structure for episodic storytelling. Each episode of the TV show could focus on a different case while contributing to the larger narrative of Judge Fleming’s crime. Because the film has a short runtime, it compresses elements that deserve to be dissected.

Al Pacino as Arthur Kirkland is absolutely electrifying, but his struggles with integrity in a corrupt system isn’t something that …And Justice For All fully explores. In a series format, audiences would get to know more about the lawyer. Certain things about his private life, like his relationship with his ex-wife and kids, are merely mentioned in the movie. A series, however, presents an opportunity to really get to know this character and what makes him tick. It’s a chance for audiences to witness the long-term consequences of Kirkland’s actions and to also sympathize and understand his passion.

…And Justice For All, is, more than anything else, a critique of the justice system, ethical gray areas, and judicial misconduct. While the movie does its best to bring these issues to light, it only scratches the surface. Doing the story through a series format, on the other hand, has the opportunity to show how systematic problems interconnect and also explore different facets of the legal system that the film didn’t really get into.

Pacino’s classic movie is so popular not only because of the morally complex characters, but because of the supporting cast. Several characters, like Jay Porter (Jeffrey Tambor), Jeff McCullaugh (Thomas G. Waites), and Ralph Agee (Robert Christian), have such nuanced story arcs that would work exceptionally well if they were given time to breathe.

Ultimately, ...And Justice For All has a kind of story that is inherently better suited for long-form storytelling, and it would shine in today’s TV landscape, more so because audiences now crave stories that take the time to explore issues that not only matter but also don’t forget the human aspect of it all.

Release Date

October 19, 1979

Runtime

119 minutes

Director

Norman Jewison

Writers

Barry Levinson

Producers

Joe Wizan

• 

• 

  Jack Warden

  Judge Francis Rayford

• 

  John Forsythe

  Judge Henry T. Fleming

• 

  Lee Strasberg

  Grandpa Sam