[
Americans are filing for unemployment at the slowest four-week pace on record. Goldman Sachs gives that about a year.
“This year began with fears of a looming AI-driven layoff wave, but the layoff rate instead remained historically low,” Goldman economists wrote in their 2027 U.S. outlook, published Sunday night. They expect this “slightly softer low-hire, low-fire form of full employment” will last one more year “before AI displacement begins to have a larger impact in subsequent years.”
Goldman has been arguing that AI job losses are just waiting on a downturn to be felt in force. In October 2025, Goldman’s U.S. economists David Mericle and Pierfrancesco Mei called “jobless growth” the likely new normal. “History also suggests that the full consequences of AI for the labor market might not become apparent until a recession hits,” they predicted.
Last month, Goldman economist Joseph Briggs estimated that up to 9% of workers could be “displaced during the AI transition,” roughly one in 11. He found that “automation-related labor disruption is limited when the overall economy is healthy but accelerates during cyclical slowdowns.” The share of Americans in routine jobs, such as clerks, secretaries and machine operators, dropped in steps during the recessions of the early 1980s, 2001, 2008 and 2020, and didn’t climb back. The McKinsey Global Institute has projected that 6 million to 16 million U.S. workers may need to switch occupations by 2035, or about 7% of current employees at the midpoint of that range.
For workers, the effects so far have shown up in stagnant hiring, rather than elevated layoffs. Employers made 5.4 million hires in September, a rate of 3.4%. Layoffs held at 1.6 million, or 1% of payrolls, according to the Labor Department’s latest JOLTS report.
Initial jobless claims rose by 9,000 to 200,000 in the week ended Nov. 7. The four-week average was flat at 195,000, which Goldman said Thursday is “remaining at its lowest level in the series’ history.” Weekly claims touched 189,000 in mid-July, the lowest since 1969, according to Reuters. In the same week a year ago they were 228,000. Goldman says wage growth has settled at about 3.5%, which it calls “a subdued pace.”
The 2027 outlook sees 2027 GDP growth at 2.4%, which it says is above consensus, and doesn’t forecast a recession. That leaves the hit to payrolls for “subsequent years.”
A giant grain of salt
There’s another reading of what’s going on, or not going on: AI may be what Princeton computer scientists Arvind Narayanan and Sayash Kapoor called, in a 2025 essay, a “normal technology.” Narayanan, co-author of AI Snake Oil, has pushed back on the idea that generative AI is about to eliminate vast swaths of white-collar work. He compares work to a sandwich whose bun is growing even as the meat shrinks, with more checking, supervision and verification around a smaller core of tasks. He still calls AI “very useful for every knowledge worker.” His preferred analogy is that AI will do for cognitive work what cranes did for physical work: we still build skyscrapers, he previously told Fortune, we just don’t carry the steel ourselves.
Richard Hanania, a political writer, pushed the idea further in a Nov. 9 essay. Global growth averaged 3.2% a year from 2010 to 2019 and 2.9% from 2023 to 2025, he wrote, citing the World Bank, while interest rates “look pretty normal.” Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei predicted in May 2025 that AI could wipe out half of entry-level white-collar jobs and push unemployment to 10% to 20% within one to five years. But Hanania said “You have to try really hard to see any progression toward that point.” Amodei has since reached for the Jevons paradox, Fortune reported in May: “If you automate 90% of the job, then everyone does the 10% of the job.”
Hanania listed eight reasons a middle manager might keep employees around even after AI can produce their reports and spreadsheets. No. 1 is “To have people to boss around.” No. 8 is “To not feel like a bad guy for cutting jobs.” Others include having “someone to share blame with if things go wrong” and people “loyal to him personally” in “factional struggles.”
Human psychology and “sticky norms” put “real limits on how efficient the economy can be,” he explained. “Surely some jobs will go away, as they always have,” he acknowledged, while largely arguing that a lot of current work will find a way to survive. The essay carries a sponsorship from Mechanize, a startup whose stated aim is the automation of all work.
Stanford’s Digital Economy Lab gives each side something. In an August update, Erik Brynjolfsson, Bharat Chandar and Ruyu Chen wrote, “We do not see widespread, economy-wide job displacement associated with AI.” But they found employment of 22- to 25-year-olds in the most AI-exposed jobs was about 19% below where it would be had it kept pace with similarly aged workers in less exposed jobs, up from 15% a year earlier. “The adjustment appears to operate primarily through reduced hiring of young workers rather than increased separations,” they wrote, calling the patterns descriptive, not causal.
Goldman calls its forecast a best guess, and its own history explains the timing: companies tend to “automate work and shed labor costs when the economy starts to slow,” Briggs wrote last month. But there might be a more human, altogether less productivity-focused, even less capitalistic reason that work and jobs exist. No. 2 on Hanania’s list: “To have people to talk to and get lunch with at work.”
https://fortune.com/img-assets/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/GettyImages-2235886163-e1794838128277.jpg?resize=1200,600
https://fortune.com/2026/11/16/why-no-ai-layoff-wave-goldman-sachs-outlook-recession-jobs/
Nick Lichtenberg




