‘The circulatory system isn’t working.’ Goldman on what’s really wrong with private markets

Hold periods for buyout-backed companies have stretched to nearly seven years, up from five-and-a-half a decade ago. Distributions to investors, the lifeblood of the entire ecosystem, have fallen far below the historical norm of 15%-20%. The average venture-backed company now takes 14 years to go public. And retail investors who piled into private credit vehicles — at a 60% annualized rate for five consecutive years — recently found themselves unable to withdraw their money when they asked.

“The circulatory system is not working,” said Michael Brandmeyer, global head and CIO of the External Investing Group at Goldman Sachs Asset Management, on an episode of the bank’s Exchanges podcast. “And so, that’s making fundraising harder. It’s driving consolidation. It’s driving a lot of change in the industry.”

Between the Global Financial Crisis and the Fed’s rate-hiking cycle, private markets experienced what Brandmeyer describes as “a period of unprecedented growth” — a sixfold expansion over roughly 12 years. Cheap money, compressed volatility, and a sustained hunt for yield made alternatives an easy sell, and capital poured in.

The problem wasn’t just that financing got more expensive. Private equity portfolios — leveraged by design, typically structured as one part equity to one part debt — were suddenly worth less, but the marks were slow to reflect that. With sellers holding out for pre-rate-hike valuations and buyers unwilling to pay them, deal flow essentially froze. North American buyout holding periods have climbed to around seven years, per Bain’s 2026 Global Private Equity Report.

“We think what’s happening is things are really going to return to historical norms,” said Pete Lyon, Goldman’s global co-head of Capital Solutions. “But it’s going to take some time.”

Lyon pushed back hard on what he called a “conflation in the press between what is actually a systemic credit problem and what is not.” His read: current default rates are nowhere near the 10%-plus levels seen during the GFC — and even under severe stress, total losses would amount to perhaps 5%, compared to the 50%-plus peak-to-trough drawdown in public equity markets during the financial crisis.

But independent data tells a more complicated story. Fitch Ratings’ U.S. Private Credit Default Rate — which tracks distressed exchanges and payment-in-kind conversions alongside outright defaults — climbed from 5.8% in January 2026 to 7.0% by April. Proskauer’s Private Credit Default Index, which monitors nearly 700 loans totaling $189 billion, recorded a 2.73% default rate in Q1 2026, up from 1.84% a year prior.

Goldman acknowledged pockets of stress — particularly in software-centric companies and those over-levered coming out of the 2021–22 LBO boom — but drew a firm line at calling it a systemic credit crisis. The liquidity crunch in retail vehicles, Lyon argued, reflected investor misunderstanding rather than a flaw in the asset class itself.

“We’re in the middle of a market structure change,” Lyon said. “We have a situation here in alternatives where market structures are evolving very quickly.” At the same time, he made the distinction that historical averages in terms of defaults and underperformance make clear that we’re nowhere close to those averages. The retail liquidity squeeze, he argued, was “broadly an education point” where investors simply hadn’t understood that illiquidity is the product, not a flaw in it.

“We are at a big inflection point right now,” Brandmeyer agreed, “and there is certainly a lot of stuff going on,” but the data show this is not a systemic issue.

Illiquidity premium under pressure

Lurking beneath the distribution problem is a more fundamental challenge to the private equity value proposition.

For the first time in decades, the three-year rolling alpha of private equity relative to public markets has gone negative. Public markets surged 40% to 50% over two years while private equity marks, smoothed by design, failed to keep pace. Brandmeyer said he’s getting one question a lot, even at cocktail parties: “Should I still be having this allocation to private equity?”

Goldman’s response is that the comparison is cyclical rather than structural. Private equity historically shows its strongest outperformance when public markets are flat or modestly positive — and looks weakest precisely when public markets are ripping. “Alpha is cyclical in the private markets,” Brandmeyer said. “And that’s because private equity is a levered asset class. It is pro-cyclical.”

The secondary market is the most immediate relief valve. Goldman estimates it will grow from roughly $250 billion today to $500 billion within three to five years. The global secondary market hit $240 billion in transaction volume in 2025 — a 48% year-over-year jump and the largest year on record, according to Jefferies — with Lazard independently corroborating a 53% surge to $233 billion.

The IPO backlog has been building for months. Deal mandates at Goldman are, in Brandmeyer’s words, “very considerable.” The firm’s base case: pent-up supply, combined with renewed LP pressure on GPs to return capital, will drive normalization over the next 1 to 3 years — potentially exceeding the 2021 market peak if geopolitics cooperate. “But for the Iran War, we think that 2026 was setting up to be a great year,” Brandmeyer said.

The longer-term structural argument is about where the innovation economy now lives. The average VC-backed company takes 14 years to go public because it no longer needs to — tens of billions in private capital are available without the disclosure obligations and quarterly earnings pressure of public markets. Amazon went public in 1997 to raise $54 million. That era is over. “Most of the innovation out there in terms of new companies is going to live in the private markets,” Brandmeyer said. “I don’t see that changing, honestly.”

Goldman also sees the current stress accelerating an industry shakeout that was already underway. A “barbell-like structure” is forming: large multi-line public asset managers on one end, highly specialized boutiques with strong alpha on the other. Goldman, of course, sits comfortably at the large end of that barbell — with “a front row seat,” as Lyon put it, across agency, asset, and wealth management businesses. Its reassuring read on private markets is informed by that perch, but it’s also shaped by it.