The Weakest Storyline in the Red Rising Trilogy Is Even Worse 10 Years Later



[

Pierce Brown‘s Red Rising trilogy is among the best works of science fiction produced in the 2010s. Starting as a classic take on the YA genre that dominated the early half of the decade, the series soon evolved into something more mature, a harsh but ultimately cathartic depiction of space war that effortlessly blended large-scale mayhem with a more coming-of-age arc — a galactic bildungsroman, if you will.

A huge portion of the story concerns the blossoming, complicated romance between protagonist Darrow and Virginia “Mustang” au Augustus. The two spend most of the trilogy trying to determine the nature of their feelings for each other, ultimately marrying and starting a family. Yet, the relationship has always felt incomplete at best and outright unconvincing at worst, especially when revisiting the trilogy. To make matters worse, there is another potential romantic partner for Darrow who would’ve made more sense and been more in line with the trilogy’s larger themes about growing up and embracing change and opportunity.

What Is Red Rising About?

Cover of 'Red Rising' by Pierce Brown
Cover of ‘Red Rising’ by Pierce Brown
Image via Del Rey Books

The Red Rising trilogy is set in a futuristic version of the Solar System ruled by The Society, a government system that divides everyone into colors depending on their role. At the top are the Golds, the undisputed rulers of the pyramid; at the very bottom are the Reds, slaves who perform the lowest and most dangerous tasks. The main story centers on Darrow, a Red helldiver from Mars whose wife is killed by the archgovernor of Mars, Nero au Augustus. Presumed dead, Darrow is instead recruited into the Sons of Ares, a rebellious faction seeking to overthrow The Society. Genetically modified and turned into a Gold, Darrow is infiltrated into Gold society to sabotage them from within.

The first book, Red Rising, sees Darrow enrolling in the Institute, where teen Golds go to learn the art of war and the ruthlessness of The Society. There, Darrow meets a young girl whom he nicknames Mustang, developing deep feelings for her after she saves his life following an attack. Mustang turns out to be Nero’s daughter, the first complication in their dynamic. To continue his plan, Darrow enters Nero’s service after The Institute, eventually kickstarting a civil war on Mars in the second book, Golden Son. The book ends with Darrow revealing his Red identity to a shocked Mustang, who feels justifiably betrayed by his deception.

In the third book, Morning Star, Darrow escapes from captivity and takes leadership of the Sons of Ares. The Solar System is now in open war, as multiple factions are in rebellion against The Society and its Sovereign, Octavia au Lune. Once again, Darrow and Mustang ally to fight the common enemy, eventually (finally, more like it) getting together — for real, this time. Their status before this book is both complicated and, more frustratingly, unclear, which is the main reason why their relationship feels incomplete.

Darrow and Mustang’s Relationship Is Underdeveloped

Cover of 'Golden Son' by Pierce Brown Image via Random House Worlds

One of the biggest issues in the Red Rising trilogy is how granular Brown gets with some sequences — particularly the ambitious and admittedly immersive action set pieces — at the expense of some of the big-picture worldbuilding and character arcs. Nowhere is that flaw more apparent than in the Darrow-Mustang relationship. Red Rising does a solid job laying the foundations of their eventual romance, although it’s far more concerned with The Institute’s war game and Darrow’s ascent to become Primus.

However, the real problem happens in Golden Son, which takes place two years after Red Rising. In that time, Darrow and Mustang’s connection has deepened, and they have even been intimate — that is to say, they fall in love off the page. From there, Brown tells us about their relationship rather than showing us, a huge point against the believability of the romance. It doesn’t help that Darrow is haunted by the memory of Eo, his dead wife and the main reason why he wants to overthrow the Golds. There’s also the little detail that Darrow is lying to Mustang about his identity, always keeping her at arm’s length out of fear of her finding out his Red nature. His fears eventually prove right, as Mustang reacts with justifiable shock, hurt, and apprehension.

It’s precisely here that the core issue with Darrow and Mustang lies. Their relationship is based on a lie, with Darrow constantly guilty and afraid, and Mustang second-guessing everything because she can sense his reluctance to open up. There’s also a huge trust chasm between the two that extends to both their role as leaders in the war and their more intimate dynamic with each other. The truth is, for most of the saga, Darrow and Mustang don’t trust each other, and thus can’t fully trust the validity or nature of their feelings. By the time they actually get together at the end of Morning Star, it doesn’t feel earned or even triumphant; rather, it feels like the end of an unnecessarily long race where the contestant limped towards the finish line, crossing it out of duty rather than genuine desire.

COLLIDERInteractive

Crew Projection

Sci-Fi/Quizzes/Hero Match

PAUL ATREIDESCAPTAIN KIRKPRINCESS LEIAELLEN RIPLEYMAX ROCKATANSKY

Collider QuizWhich Sci-Fi Hero
Are You
8 Questions · 5 LegendsFive iconic heroes. Five completely different ways of facing an impossible universe. One of them shares your instincts, your values, and your particular way of refusing to back down. Eight questions will tell you which one.On The Manifest

Paul Atreides

Captain Kirk

Princess Leia

Ellen Ripley

Max Rockatansky

Your Hero Has Been IdentifiedYour Sci-Fi Hero Is

Your answers point to the iconic sci-fi hero who shares your instincts, your values,
and your particular way of facing the impossible.

DunePaul AtreidesArrakis · Dune, 2021The hero who knows exactly what becoming one will cost.

You carry a weight most people would crumble under: the knowledge of what you’re capable of, and the burden of what you might have to become.Why This Is You

  • You see further ahead than others and you plan accordingly, even when the vision frightens
    you.
  • You are driven by loyalty to your people and a sense of destiny you didn’t ask for but
    can’t escape.
  • Paul Atreides is not simply a hero. He is someone who understands the cost of power and
    chooses to bear it anyway.
  • That gravity, that willingness to carry what others won’t, is exactly you.

From The Collider File

  • Dune: Part Three closes Denis Villeneuve’s trilogy on December 18, 2026, adapting Dune
    Messiah.
  • Messiah is the book that turns on its own hero, which is why Villeneuve waited to film it.

Sees It ComingCarries The WeightArrakis

Star TrekCaptain KirkUSS Enterprise · Star Trek, 1966The captain who refuses to accept that a no-win scenario exists.

You lead with instinct, warmth, and an absolute refusal to accept a no-win scenario, because you’ve always believed there’s a third option nobody else has thought of yet.Why This Is You

  • You take the mission seriously without ever taking yourself too seriously.
  • Your crew would follow you anywhere, not because you demand it, but because you’ve
    earned it.
  • Kirk’s genius isn’t tactical, it’s human. He reads people, bends rules with
    purpose, and wills outcomes into existence through sheer conviction.
  • That combination of warmth, audacity, and relentless optimism is unmistakably yours.

From The Collider File

  • Paul Wesley’s Kirk took the center chair in Strange New Worlds season 4, which
    premiered July 23, 2026.
  • The producers have confirmed Kirk stays with the show through its final season.

No-Win ScenarioCrew FirstStarfleet

Star WarsPrincess LeiaThe Rebellion · A New Hope, 1977The one who holds the line when the line is all that’s left.

You are the kind of person who holds the line when everyone else is losing faith, not because you’re fearless, but because giving up simply isn’t something you’re capable of.Why This Is You

  • You lead through conviction. Your voice carries because your belief is unshakable.
  • You gave up everything ordinary the moment you chose the cause, and you’ve never looked
    back.
  • Leia is not a supporting character in her own story. She is the moral center of the entire
    rebellion.
  • That same fierce, principled, unbreakable core is what defines you.

From The Collider File

  • Carrie Fisher was 19 when she shot A New Hope, and Leia’s first scene in the saga is a
    refusal.
  • Lucasfilm ruled out recreating her digitally, so her last appearance was built from footage
    she had already filmed.

Holds The LineThe CauseRebellion

AlienEllen RipleyThe Nostromo · Alien, 1979No speeches. Just the person still standing at the end.

You are not reckless, not grandiose, and not particularly interested in being anyone’s hero. You just refuse to stop when it matters.Why This Is You

  • You see threats clearly, you document the truth even when no one listens, and when the time
    comes you handle it yourself.
  • Ripley’s heroism is earned, not performed. She doesn’t have a speech. She has a
    plan and the nerve to see it through.
  • You share her composure under the worst possible pressure, and her refusal to pretend the
    monster isn’t there.
  • When it counts, you don’t flinch. That’s everything.

From The Collider File

  • FX renewed Noah Hawley’s Alien: Earth for a second season, pushing the franchise onto
    the home planet.
  • Sigourney Weaver has said she is seriously weighing a return to Ripley after reading a new
    script.

No SpeechesHandles ItNostromo

Mad MaxMax RockatanskyThe Wasteland · Mad Max, 1979Lost everything, kept going anyway.

You have been through fire that would break most people, and what came out the other side is something the world underestimates at its peril.Why This Is You

  • You don’t ask for help, don’t need validation, and don’t wait for anyone to
    tell you the rules no longer apply.
  • Your loyalty, when it finally arrives, is absolute, but it’s earned in silence and
    tested in action, not in words.
  • Max is not a nihilist. He is someone who lost everything and found, against his will, that
    he still has something worth protecting.
  • That bruised, stubborn, ultimately human core is exactly yours.

From The Collider File

  • George Miller has a script for the next Mad Max, The Wasteland, but has said only that we
    will see whether it gets made.
  • The 1979 original was shot for a few hundred thousand Australian dollars and became one of
    the most profitable films ever made.

Outlasts ItEarned LoyaltyWasteland

Crew Match

1· · ·0%

2· · ·0%

3· · ·0%

A Collider InteractiveCOLLIDERMore quizzes at collider.com

Darrow and Victra Made Far More Sense as a Couple

Morning-Star book cover Image via Companion Press

Red Rising is hardly the only sci-fi epic with a weak central romance. After all, many authors struggle to balance the intricate worldbuilding needed to bring these tales to life with the more intimate quality that makes any successful romance work. For example, and for all its many, many strengths, Frank Herbert‘s Dune and the Harry Potter saga also arguably fail in the romance department. However, what makes the Red Rising central couple feel weaker is the fact that there is another, equally iconic character who would’ve made far more sense as Darrow’s partner.

Victra au Julii is one of Darrow’s fiercest and most staunchly loyal allies, harboring an open and unrequited crush on him. Because Darrow’s love for Mustang is so unconvincing, his rejection of Victra feels puzzling and outright frustrating. See, Brown actually spends time developing Darrow and Victra’s bond, largely because it comes as a result of their time in battle — because their connection is born in the heat of war, we actually get to see it blossoming.

There’s also the fact that Victra’s love for Darrow was never dependent on his status as a Gold, his deeds, or his status as the Reaper. She has no particular reaction to learning that he was a Red because she always saw the person, not the color or the title. Her loyalty is to him, born out of respect, admiration, love, and an appreciation for his tactical mind and resourceful nature. Moreover, while Darrow and Mustang’s bond feels youthful and hopeful, Darrow and Victra’s feels mature and solid: they’ve been through hell and back together, and not only survived but thrived. Sadly, Victra ends up with Sevro, one of Brown’s most head-scratching developments.

In the end, the Darrow-Mustang romance feels more forced than anything, a remnant of the saga’s origins as YA fiction, as if Brown left them together because he felt like he needed to, rather than because it made the most sense. Many stories do the same, especially if they think the fans will not accept the protagonist with anyone else — indeed, the concept of an “endgame” couple has caused much damage to far too many stories. Red Rising is one such example. Darrow and Mustang might be the safe, expected choice, but Darrow and Victra feel organic and are far more interesting. And in a story as ambitious as this one, “interesting” is always better than “safe.”

https://static0.colliderimages.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/red-rising-bastien-lecouffe-special-edition.jpg?w=1600&h=900&fit=crop
https://collider.com/red-rising-book-trilogy-darrow-mustang-weakest-storyline/


David Caballero
Almontather Rassoul

Latest articles

spot_imgspot_img

Related articles

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

spot_imgspot_img